According to progressives, if we “offer” red state voters something they’ll magically throw away their white privilege/white nationalist beliefs and be in favor gay marriage and socialism!
Here we can see that it’s easier for some people to believe that all red-state voters are just irredeemably racist or ignorant than to grapple with the structural failures of the Democratic Party and the broader political system. The reality is, many working-class voters in red states
already support progressive policies when framed outside of partisan identity. Things like higher minimum wages, Medicare for All, legal weed, and strong labor protections often pass via ballot initiatives even in deep red states. The issue isn’t that these voters are ideologically opposed to progressive policies—it’s that the Democratic Party, for decades, has failed to counter right-wing propaganda effectively, or offer a real populist alternative. They've completely eroded the trust that voters gave them in previous generations.
Another lazy narrative that absolves the Democratic establishment of responsibility while making no attempt to win over people who could be reached with real, material policies. This argument also showcases a deep misunderstanding of how politics actually works. People don’t vote based on policy they vote based on identity, trust, culture, and who they feel speaks for them. The right has spent decades perfecting a strategy of culture war, while the Democrats have failed to counter it in any way that would resonate with working-class voters. The Democratic party has no identity