I don't wanna open that can but Interstellar definitely had more spectacle. But it also had 3x the budget.
Interstellar tried to do more things. Probably (definitely) too many things at once...
Still, the scene with breh checking his messages had more emotion than anything in Arrival.
I'm still feeling slighted. Once I understood where the ending was going, once I understood the gravity of it - and its not some hard to understand thing - I was waiting for Amy Adams to bring it home. The director, cinematographer, and writer laid out the perfect stage for guts to get wrenched but it never happened. There was simply a point in the movie where things intertwined. The emotion and passion was just simply absent in this movie. The kid is the best part but she's a
device, not a player.