Majestic Pape
The-Coli = W SOHH = L
Still, it woulda been crazy if he had been on some Deion/Bo type shyt.
If we ever got a player on some NFL/NBA double-play shyt in this day and age that would be

Edit: I nominate Nate Robinson. He's the guy I think has the best athletic ability and actually played at a high level of college football. Plus he might not be overwhelmed by the risk of a football injury (like, say, a LeBron couldn't afford), he loves the attention that would come from it, and he's crazy enough/good enough stamina to try it.
He wouldn't be "elite" in either sport I don't think though.