Do you see a scenario where an NFL HC who doesn’t win a Super Bowl Makes the HOF going forward?

[FukkaPaidEmail]

If Dan Campbell crazy ass keeps this up and goes on a SF Shanahan type run without winning one I can see just because him and Holmes make the Lions functional

 

[FukkaPaidEmail]

The innovation point is another good one …Dan Quinn ain’t win shyt and may never do…but the Cover 3 Match shyt has changed the way defense is played on all levels

Rich Rodriquez hasn’t won big in college but RPO’s has changed offenses to a high level …should he be a CFB hof’er?

 

[Street Knowledge]

Absolutely not because anybody could get hot and win one.

What is more impressive, McVay winning one super bowl or Levy coaching a team to 4 straight? Levy didn't win one but he put himself in position to win 4. I think there is a 0% chance McVay could ever get to 4 straight super bowls. Not patient enough and doesn't strike me as the type of coach who can keep a group of players that focused for that long. I am way more impressed with Levy getting to 4 in a row than with McVay getting to 2 and winning one.

I would take the NFC that Sean Mcvay coached against in his career over the AFC Marv levy went to 4 straight superbowls in though.

 

[Regular_P]

Shanny is 100% a Hall of Famer. He went to two Super Bowls with Jimmy G and Brock Purdy as his QBs.

 

[mastermind]

-Coryell and Allen are the two here I don't really get how they are in, but I'm open to listening to arguments. I get that Coryell had some lasting impact with his offensive scheme and that he had support of former coaches to get in, but doesn't seem like someone that is THAT worthy of the highest honor

coryell is responsible for the modern NFL offense

i will give you Allen tho. He always won and it was probably that era.

Also he died while coaching

 

[yseJ]

head coach is a job which is very results-driven

unlike players who cant really have responsibilities over other players beyond their control, head coaches/gms assemble teams to win it all. so they will be ultimately judged for rings or lack of them

 

[3Rivers]

Every coach takes the job to win apart from The Cowboys HC.

I know he eventually won in the end with another team. But Dungy's Tampa 2 has a greater impact on the game than Gruden winning the title with them. So even if Dungy didn't win a SB he deserved to be recognised for how he helped evolve the game.

I'd put Dungy in off of winning a lot of games in addition to the SB win/multiple appearances/turning around two franchises. It's funny that it's referred to as the Tampa 2 when Dungy himself said he was simply running the same defense Bud Carson ran in the 70s with the Steelers.

 

[King Poetic]

Say if a coach pulls a Mike Tomlin and have nothing but winning seasons as a coach and make 2 Super Bowl appearances then yeah

 

[Stop_It_5]

Didn't realize it before this thread - how is Mike Holmgren not in ?

 

[mastermind]

Didn't realize it before this thread - how is Mike Holmgren not in ?

Great question

His coaching tree is almost as strong as Bill Walsh’s. He has the Super Bowl and appearances.

My only guess is he isn’t liked that much in the football community.