sporticus
https://bit.ly/36fn72e
I'm sorry, but all you cats mentioning Aaliyah.....stop it. Babygirl died too young and had some good songs, but she got overrated because of her death. She wouldn't even be mentioned in that space otherwise.
Does Beyoncés overall greatness make people forget about her great singing capability??
- Thread starter Standing on business
- Start date
MooseMouthMthafuga
Veteran
I'm not duckin chit.
you still havnt showed face in that silk thread. I tagged you before this. and you still havnt responded in those 2 or 3 other threads. and I tagged you in those as well. you responded to one and then prompty ducked back out.
and stop trying to make me seem like I have a weird obsession with Aaliyah. youre not smart enough to swing perception on the slick.
I just don't like revisionist history and I don't like lines being blurred(and both of those apply to Aaliyah. and its pretty obvious if you look at the names that I'm synonymous with supposedly hating on here. its not about me hating these artists. if anything, the people I hate are the dikkhead posters like yourself that like to pedal that chit.
and whats funny is you already f*cked up earlier in this thread and made a post that un-intentionally agreed with darn near everything I be saying.
I'm not wasting my time getting into a back-n-forth with somebody who just said that the dream revolutionized r&b.
youre a known culture-vulture that never knows what youre talking about ever. and now youre trying to bring your miseducated essays into r&b threads.
GET THE F*CK OUTTA HERE.
her whole style & swag was bitten. and the guy who gave her that swag, was a notorious biter himself.
chicks dug ALOT of singers. not just Aaliyah. nor was she amongst the most popular.
theres nothing "off the block" about Aaliyah breh. I think "the girl next door that I might have a chance with" is the term that youre looking for.
you do know that Aaliyah only got in the game because her uncle is barry Hankerson right? you really don't want to get into the backgrounds breh. theres nothing organic about Aaliyah's come-up.
I don't know everything about her, but Aaliyah's music feels more organic to me.I guess she fooled me better than Bey
010101
C L O N E*0690//////
bey works like nobody else salute her for that
but she's a cornball with zero organic wave
even with the gawdbawdy team feeding her looks and artistic concepts she just comes across as a tryhard
the aaliyah comparison to me is like the complete opposite of her
liyah just had this ease to everything she did
her music is more enjoyable across the board
*
but she's a cornball with zero organic wave
even with the gawdbawdy team feeding her looks and artistic concepts she just comes across as a tryhard
the aaliyah comparison to me is like the complete opposite of her
liyah just had this ease to everything she did
her music is more enjoyable across the board
*
thats literally the only song I fukk with heavy from her
Homeboy Runny-Ray
From Around The Way
that's because all Aaliyah did was throw some shades on like t-boz and hum over r.kelly/timbaland/missy beats that she got courtesy of her uncle.
man that Aaliyah post-death propaganda machine got yall fooled. its SPOOKY in here man.
I don't know everything about her, but Aaliyah's music feels more organic to me.I guess she fooled me better than Bey
well now you know better, and what I posted wasn't even the half.
if you live in denial after this, its on you breh.
onelastdeath
Banned
Beyonce is the best overall performer since MJ
Who's saying she can't sing better than Aaliyah and Mary J
some bullshyt strawman argument OP set up.
she can sing but i don't feel it
beyonce lacks a certain emotion that comes when singin' with emotion
i think her singin' is bland
very bland.
that uncomfortable truth
as soon as I read this post, I knew these frauds would go silent
Common Coli tactic. OP makes some goofy statement, others show up pretending to be fans, but when asked to show knowledge of catalog, they fail or go mute.I never bump Beyonce but she has some decent tracks. "Partition" is lowkey one of the best beats she's ever sang on. and aside from the chorus, she doesn't really fit imo. Beyonce's not the dark/experimental type. Aaliyah would have KILLED that beat.
the other decent cuts: "Single Ladies", "Me Myself and I", "Work It Out", "Check On It", "7/11" and "Get Me Bodied"
ETHER
Last edited:
I love Latina women
Veteran
yup
MooseMouthMthafuga
Veteran
some bullshyt strawman argument OP set up.
very bland.
that uncomfortable truth
as soon as I read this post, I knew these frauds would go silent
I never bump Beyonce but she has some decent tracks. "Partition" is lowkey one of the best beats she's ever sang on. and aside from the chorus, she doesn't really fit imo. Beyonce's not the dark/experimental type. Aaliyah would have KILLED that beat.
the other decent cuts: "Single Ladies", "Me Myself and I", "Work It Out", "Check On It", "7/11" and "Get Me Bodied"
ETHER
I guess my mind's been outside of the Matrix for far too long.
I see these "programs" all to vividly now
I'm willing to call her the best/most expensive piece of plastic in the plastic shop.That I'll concede
MooseMouthMthafuga
Veteran
You could tell me everything you know, but musically----strictly talking about the sound/vibe of the music, Aaliyah will still appeal to me more that Beyonce.
The politics surrounding how/why she got a deal really don't concern me.The bizz is filled with all types of fukkery.
I'm just saying, if i'm going to pick my poison/favorite piece of plastic, generic Aaliyah>generic Beyonce.
They're both robots.Aaliyah and her handlers did a better job at making her sound closer to being "human"
IMO
010101
C L O N E*0690//////
i acknowledge beyonce being the stronger vocalist and a more polished performer
but it's about who's music i enjoy more
aaliyah is the more pleasing artist in every respect for me
even with me knowing bey is a machine
beyonce for me will always have this forced try hard aura on her
i can listen to her once and appreciate the work she puts in but i never want to come back
with aaliyah she has a bunch of songs i can vibe to and roll up with a tenda to
even being the weaker vocalist it's the relaxed easy quality in her voice that males it dope
kick the beyhive and run jahahahahaa
*
I don't know man, I guees it's all about what type of shyt you prefer, to me..
My dad was a musician and traveled locally and shyt ..played keys, organ, guitar..he wrote some stuff that never took off. Cause of that me and my little bro was lowkey forced into music. Went to performing arts schools..so because of my taste and knowledge in music I just prefer more sophisticated singing. Controlled vocals..I get distracted by off key notes, and straining and shyt..My ears be fukked up. I also like smart singers that know about chords and scales, know how to progress melodies with improv..all that technical shyt because I play keys. Beyonce gives all of this (she's techically on pitch, with crazy agility..think of an organist "shredding" on the keys.. she handles that shyt like an instrument..So I respect her ability and people look over it cause the see that ass or see how beautiful she is but when you see her live, you get to hear how vocally underrated she is.
start at around 5:30 and just watch a few minutes..bytch voice like a jazz trumpetier. I fukks with it.
My dad was a musician and traveled locally and shyt ..played keys, organ, guitar..he wrote some stuff that never took off. Cause of that me and my little bro was lowkey forced into music. Went to performing arts schools..so because of my taste and knowledge in music I just prefer more sophisticated singing. Controlled vocals..I get distracted by off key notes, and straining and shyt..My ears be fukked up. I also like smart singers that know about chords and scales, know how to progress melodies with improv..all that technical shyt because I play keys. Beyonce gives all of this (she's techically on pitch, with crazy agility..think of an organist "shredding" on the keys.. she handles that shyt like an instrument..So I respect her ability and people look over it cause the see that ass or see how beautiful she is but when you see her live, you get to hear how vocally underrated she is.
start at around 5:30 and just watch a few minutes..bytch voice like a jazz trumpetier. I fukks with it.
Serious question
Everyone acklowdeges that she's a great performer and there's no debate to that. But reading that she's not that great of a singer, and things like she can't sing better than Aaliyah, Monica, Mary, brandy etc has me a bit stumped.
Whose songs you like better will always be an opinion but how the hell are people overlooking her superior vocal talent?
She can sing or dance better than Aaliyah.......
Aaliyah
Gtfoh
I think some people have a hard time differentiating someone who can not sing vs not liking someone's actual singing voice.
I don't like Beyonce's singing voice. It does nothing for me. However, I can recognize that she can actually sing.
Homeboy Runny-Ray
From Around The Way
You could tell me everything you know, but musically----strictly talking about the sound/vibe of the music, Aaliyah will still appeal to me more that Beyonce.
The politics surrounding how/why she got a deal really don't concern me.The bizz is filled with all types of fukkery.
I'm just saying, if i'm going to pick my poison/favorite piece of plastic, generic Aaliyah>generic Beyonce.
They're both robots.Aaliyah and her handlers did a better job at making her sound closer to being "human"
its not about who you prefer to listen to. i'll put an Aaliyah record on before beyonce too. but in reality, I know I'm really just doing it for r.kelly or missy & timbaland.
Aaliyah was brought up in here as some sort of barrier or better option, when in reality, she wasn't much of a talent. she was moreso a novelty act.
that perspective is needed.
no theyre not BOTH robots. Aaliyah was but beyonce isn't. beyonce can actually sing, she writes at least some of the stuff she takes credit for and shes a great performer.
Alicia Keys 1st two albums received just as much, if not more critical acclaim, than Beyonce's last two albums, and that's her and Kerry Brothers competing against the entire Beyhive Tent Camp
Alicia Keys also isn't signed directly to the largest tour company in the world, so comparing tours isn't a fair argument