How often do you go to shows jw? Are you a casual observer or do you actually seek out live comedy? The experience is a lot different. You're only seeing them in big venues with edits and such. And you can't really use chappelle because he's actually a comedic freak of nature.
Never been to a live comedy show, but i don't see how watching it on TV vs watching it live would have THAT big an effect on whether or not I find the material funny. I didn't have to see Eddie Murphy or Richard Pryor live to find them funny

which kind of makes sense, they see the successful acts doing it. takes a bold comedian to buck the trend. I'm hoping for that transformation though