The Rush Limbaugh shyt went down in 03 and they got TO in 04 so we can call that a wash. I'm not saying he should've been on some Cam Newton shyt, but he wouldn't even run to make the plays that mattered after that. Hell, Elway had the helicopter TD run in the super bowl when he was like 36. McNabb wouldn't pick up an easy first with nobody in front of him. But that's just my perspective. Like you said, we can agree to disagree.
I will leave it at this. Like I said two year after getting TO. In 2005 mcnabb gets his sternum crushed vs the falcons plays hurt the season and gets gets his groan injured which later rips off his thigh in a game versus Dallas. He comes back the next year and doesn't even make the whole season he blows out his knee RUNNING vs the titans....during this season the Eagles offense was on pace to have the most passing yards in a season and Andy was passing the ball 70% of the time.
If you look at his stats his rushing yards reduce each of these years (2004 with TO, 2005 the season they deactivated TO and Mcnabb had sternum and groan injuries and 2006 when Mcnabb blew his knee out). Also in 2003 is a year where he had career high in rushing yards and had a game where he had almost 100 yards rushing and almost 300 yards passing vs the packers in a playoff win.
Oh and lets not forget that McNabb in his last season with the Eagles he had his ribs broken vs the Panthers running into the end zone for a touch down which was a 10 yard run only to have a Panthers player illegally spear him in his back.
But we will just agree to disagree.