I was kinda "meh" to Batista, but his match versus Taker at WrestleMania was such a pleasant surprise. It was my favorite match on the PPV and then he followed it up with more matches with Taker that were really good, I became a fan.
I wasn't feeling Bray Wyatt like a lot of people here until his match with Daniel Bryan at Royal Rumble and it turned me into a fan.
And I had the same view of Ziggler that the threadstarter had till his match with Rey at SummerSlam.