Dr. Narcisse
Veteran
Warrick Dunn >> 
Edgerrin James vs Fred Taylor
- Thread starter Freddie.Cane
- Start date
If u say what could have been then of course Taylor but if u going with what happened its EJ
NYC Rebel
...on the otherside of the pond
I need to think about this.....
I was a HUGE Fred Taylor fan when he played for Florida. He was slept on to me coming out of college. Great pro....same with Edge.
I have to go with Edge. He and John Riggins had the best "forward lean" at running back ever.
I was a HUGE Fred Taylor fan when he played for Florida. He was slept on to me coming out of college. Great pro....same with Edge.
I have to go with Edge. He and John Riggins had the best "forward lean" at running back ever.
I agree Doc CaneFrank Gore >>
Last edited:
STAN JONES
Fire John Harbaugh
The real answer is:
Fred Taylor was more talented.
Edge was more productive.
Fred Taylor was more talented.
Edge was more productive.
Even still, I'm taking Fred. Better player, just on worse teams.
AlbertPullhoez
The Takeover
I was a stan of those late 90's Jags squads as a kid gotta go with Fred even though he used to kill FSU
mr heyzel
All Star
edge
Edge before the injury was no slouch now he was a monster in his own right I just feel Edge was betterEven still, I'm taking Fred. Better player, just on worse teams.
Sidenote: Thank God Randy Moss never played for fspoo
AlbertPullhoez
The Takeover
Breh I feel cheated that we never got to see Mauce and Peter Warrick play together at FSUSidenote: Thank God Randy Moss never played for fspoo
Yall might have surpassed us in rings but thank every God in the world it didn't happen :Ouuuuuuu:Breh I feel cheated that we never got to see Mauce and Peter Warrick play together at FSU
Breh I feel cheated that we never got to see Mauce and Peter Warrick play together at FSU
