Elden Ring, Cyberpunk 2077, Baldur’s Gate 3, or E33 GoTG so far?

[Deafheaven]

​

gameplay is TRASH

 

[Brian O'Conner]

I got elden ring. Just finished my 4th run (on a new save for the ps5 pro) and it still hits the same. There’s so many ways to play the game with different builds, the amount of hours you can get off one purchase really makes it the goat game imo.

B3 tbh I haven’t found the time to finish it in multiple restarts it hasn’t grabbed me like that. I do appreciate the game but the difference is Elden ring is a goat game with no story, it’s just gameplay. B3 is the opposite where the story and narrative is everything than the actuall gameplay itself

E33 I never tried so can’t speak on it. The ascetic does not grab me at all it’s a game I have no interest in

 

[Gizmo_Duck]

I barely started Shadow of the Erdtree, need to finish it. I haven't bought Nightreign DLC yet. Have you finished those DLCs?

Finished Erd tree front to back, no interest in nightreign

 

[Flexington]

I think I was feeling FromSoft fatigue so I never ran back Elden Ring after finishing Erdtree. I still enjoyed the experience and it was dope figuring out shyt as everyone played and shared.

BG3 for me, I thought I was going to hate the combat but after it all began to click around getting to the Grove? No turning back

 

[Ruck]

Look at these dudes voting for Elden Ring

Over here wanting to play with swords

Got all colors of sweet pum pum on BG3

but nah, I gotta circle around and get a good backstab cuz its too euphoric

 

[Methodical]

Finished Erd tree front to back, no interest in nightreign

Why not interested in Nightreign if you loved Elden Ring that much?

 

[ReggieFlare]

I agree with you but i don’t think BG3 is overrated due to its scope alone. There’s not another role playing experience in gaming that really gives you that level of freedom with that level of production, it will never be outdone.

Witcher 4 is next up and those games are barely rpgs anymore

I mostly agree with you there but what are you referring to when it comes to freedom? Narratively? Gameplay? From a gameplay standpoint it is pretty varied but from a narrative standpoint there are other games that achieve freedom of choice to a similar degree IMO

I just think overall it’s a great game that starts very strong and ends a tad weak by the last act. Funny enough, DOS2 which Larian released before it had very similar issues with its last act

 

[Gizmo_Duck]

Why not interested in Nightreign if you loved Elden Ring that much?

Because it doesnt have the things i enjoy about souls games: exploration and discovery, builds and customization, being able to play and figure things out at my own pace, etc.

 

[Fillerguy]

I think Elden Ring, even though I hate those fukking type games. But BG3 made the that nerdy, theatre kid energy ass TTRPG a hot commodity. Gamers are hungry for more DnD media. All future crpgs will be compared to BG3, the way they were to Dragon Age before Bioware suicided their style in the sequel.

 

[Gizmo_Duck]

I think Elden Ring, even though I hate those fukking type games. But BG3 made the that nerdy, theatre kid energy ass TTRPG a hot commodity. Gamers are hungry for more DnD media. All future crpgs will be compared to BG3, the way they were to Dragon Age before Bioware suicided their style in the sequel.

The irony of all of it considering BioWare made BG1 and BG2 lol

 

[DarkandHellisHot]

From the games mentioned, none. The correct answer is Redfall. Dont @ me.

Spoiler

Never played BG3, not my type of game. Between the other 2, probably E33. Because Lune and OST slaps.

 

[hex]

I put 295 hours into "Elden Ring", beat it multiple times, etc.

I wouldn't even put it in the discussion. It's essentially open world "Dark Souls 4".

I know this isn't a popular opinion so I don't see many agreeing with me but I gotta keep it real.

Out of the three I'd say "Baldur's Gate 3" just off the freedom of gameplay alone.

Fred.

 

[Canon]

I like E33 but I feel its a littler overrated

I would say Cyberpunk,Elden Ring, and BG3 are battling it out so far

 

[Loose]

Elden ring by far

Bg3 3rd act was so mid smh

 

[Gizmo_Duck]

I like E33 but I feel its a littler overrated

I would say Cyberpunk,Elden Ring, and BG3 are battling it out so far

The complete cyberpunk+phantom liberty experience might >>>>>>