Eli Manning is the 5th best QB

[Spaceman Piff]

2 rings and people still trying to front on eli?

 

[JAY?]

Compare his body language to his brother's in crunch time. You'll see the difference instantly. Peyton gets very jittery when the walls are closing in on the game and it's in his hands. Eli doesn't.

I see what u saying but the shyt is that his brother is always playing those games
Eli had 2 great runs
But his brother is always in the mix

 

[who_better_than_me]

Im also a jets fan but I think
Brady
Peyton
Brees
Burger
Rodgers
Are clearly better

I think he's top 10 considering what he's done
But there's like 10 guys I'd pick before him easily


Brady plays emotionless
He's the ice water type
I don't see that in Eli tho

Lol, touch Brady a couple times and he start hearing footsteps that ant there. Hit Eli a couple times and everytime it look likes it the first time he been hit all light night.


Eli the poised qb in the league. Even more than Rodgers.

 

[JAY?]

Lol, touch Brady a couple times and he start hearing footsteps that ant there. Hit Eli a couple times and everytime it look likes it the first time he been hit all light night.


Eli the poised qb in the league. Even more than Rodgers.

The way the giants were hitting Brady the first sb, nobody would have a chance
That's forgotten because of the pass
But without that d game wouldn't even be close

 

[who_better_than_me]

The way the giants were hitting Brady the first sb, nobody would have a chance
That's forgotten because of the pass
But without that d game wouldn't even be close

Truth

 

[RhodyRum]

The way the giants were hitting Brady the first sb, nobody would have a chance
That's forgotten because of the pass
But without that d game wouldn't even be close

I agree with you on the D. I always say they should have given that entire DL the MVP in their first SB with Eli. In fact, of the 3 Giants Super Bowl winning QBs, Simms is still my guy if it's one game for the chip. Dude DELIVERED the Lombardi that day

 

[JAY?]

I agree with you on the D. I always say they should have given that entire DL the MVP in their first SB with Eli. In fact, of the 3 Giants Super Bowl winning QBs, Simms is still my guy if it's one game for the chip. Dude DELIVERED the Lombardi that day

that was the sickest I ever seen any line play
They seemed to be in the backfield before the ball was even snapped
It's like they all had the game of their lives

 

[AVXL]

Eli in the postseason is a scary site

In the regular season he's never really QB'd a great Giants team or consistently put together great seasons, but get him in the postseason & he balls the fukk out. He's clearly the best QB in the NFC East though, it don't matter if it ain't pretty, he gets the job done

 

[Born2BKing]

Now?
No
I don't really think any1 I mentioned is better
But watching him play, I just can't see how he wins
He looks scared out there
I was just wondering if giants fans think he's actually good

Kinda like Yankees fans
If u tell them jeter has been a below average ss for the last 5 years
They tell u how manys rings he got

Scared? He is probably the most cool, calm and collected qb in the league.

 

[Art Barr]

Scared? He is probably the most cool, calm and collected qb in the league.

nah,..
not at all!!

Brady, Eli and Peyton are happy feet the sequels and the musical on ice.


Art Barr

 

[23Barrettcity]

I'm a Jet fan. He's very, very good. He's the best 4th quarter QB in the league, and that's huge. When you say "he looks scared" you're mistaking that for his emotionless command of the O. Browning Nagle and Dave Brown looked scared. You're better with a level headed, calm QB who has ice water in his veins in crunch time over a jumpy, high/low extreme QB any day. My only criticism is he (and the team in general) play too much Kardiac Kid style football, especially last season, which is why their recent seasons are either a BIG HIT or just bust.

Exactly he's actually too fearless sometimes resulting in unnecessary to's

 

[DStyles]

That's my Elite/GOAT QB

 

[MAKAVELI25]

fukk Eli AND the Giants, but this is just a dumb ass thread

 

[chuckifubuck]

Eli is a forrest gump type retard who gets a lot of luck and doesn't feel pain cause his brain isnt developed enough for it

and Yes I'm hating

 

[mrken12]

LMAO at someone trying to say Romo is better than Eli.