Eminem vs Jay, who has the higher highs, and who got the lower lows?

[boogers]

Their lows are equal

lol yea i was gonna say maybe put 'ghetto techno' up against 'just lose it' or something... or that one jay track where he keeps quoting austin powers in the hook

to ems credit i dont think he has anything quite as putrid as i know what girls like but that stupid superman shyt is pretty close ig

im not crazy about either one of them lol. something about jay just rubs me the wrong way. like he has a plastic heart or something idk how to explain it. hes not a real person

 

[Chris Cool]

That Sean Paul bp2 song down there too.

 

[TheDarceKnight]

Their lows are equal

Nah. Jay has horrible songs here and there for sure. And ghetto techno is horrible no doubt. But Em has entire albums like Revival that are awful from start to finish. Em’s lows are lower.

 

[Uchiha God]

Jay higher highs
Em lower lows

 

[HipHopStan]

[

I think cult meetings probably have more critical thinking than the comment section of that video. It’s like a rehab clinic for people hopelessly addicted to bad taste.

 

[Street Knowledge]

I would unironically take Kingdome come over 95% if Eminem’s discography

 

[Playaz Eyez]

Em’s lows are FAR lower than Jay’s.

 

[Rasille]

Eminem is so overrated foh. Hov>>

 

[TheMailMan]

Bout as low as you can go lol

 

[CP3.]

Em definitely has lower lows and it's not close. I love dude but he might have the lowest lows of any mainstream rapper. When his shyt is bad it's BAD


Jay has higher highs but it's at least a bit closer.

 

[tysigna]

I would unironically take Kingdome come over 95% if Eminem’s discography

Whatttt

 

[Reptile]

Em’s higher highs are his skills, he don’t got many “classic” albums.

He got 3 (SSLP, MMLP, Eminem Show), just as much as Jay (RD, BP, Black Album)

 

[Reptile]

Their highs are equal, but Ems lows are much lower than Jays.

 

[Human Torch]

Argue the highs all you want but the lowest low ain’t even a debate….

 

[mundL]

Em has higher highs and lower lows

Link me a jay song where he can bodied a Track like em on lets say til i collapse or more recently the last Verse of Bad guy

Jay super laid back i can dig some of his songs but hes not a beast on the MIC like em when hes in a zone