We'll see November 15th who's better
ESPN's 2015 NFL QB Tier Rankings
- Thread starter Brady-Carter
- Start date
Gil Scott-Heroin
Veteran
Tony D'Amato
It's all about the inches
I would love to know the morons criticizing Luck's playoff performance amd division. Like Luck aint got wins over Sea, Den, GB, Bal, Cinci, and other playoff teams. And the Texans win their share of gms vs other divisions.
Then in the playoffs he lost to the Ravens during their sb season, and twice to the Pats. An underdog each time. He probably has the worst coaching staff of any playoff qb. No run gm and subpar oline play.
Then in the playoffs he lost to the Ravens during their sb season, and twice to the Pats. An underdog each time. He probably has the worst coaching staff of any playoff qb. No run gm and subpar oline play.
backbreaker65
All Star
Still in their prime
Aaron Rodgers
Tom Brady
Ben Rothlisberger
Joe Flacco
Until you can win a superbowl, and have epic comebacks to win in big games, you can't sniff those cats up above.
Andrew Luck
Tony Romo
Aaron Rodgers
Tom Brady
Ben Rothlisberger
Joe Flacco
Until you can win a superbowl, and have epic comebacks to win in big games, you can't sniff those cats up above.
Andrew Luck
Tony Romo
feelosofer
#ninergang
Ok these rankings get worse year by year. I'm becoming more convinced that ESPN doesn't watch games, they are looking at stats in a vacuum and you can't just do that. I will say this their tier one is pretty accurate though I would replace Drew Bress with Russel Wilson.
Like Kaep for instance, they didn't take into account his declining stats (which QBR aside were still pretty good) on the fact that the offensive line lost not one not two but 3 starters over the course of the season I mean our starting right tackle was JONATHAN MARTIN for most of the season, or that Vernon Davis had been schemed out of the gameplan because our WR Corp consisted Anquan Boldin (great receiver) and two clones in Stevie Johnson (who was nicked up) and Michael Crabtee who all all run 4.7 40 yards dashes but don't possess Boldin route running or toughness.
Also lol at Tannehill being worse than Alex Smith when Tanehill got better with each passing year and honestly, he's kinda been playing with a team that doesn't cater to his skillset.
Also whats with the hate on Teddy Bridgewater, he's a friggin kid and he's shown flashes of being very good, I'm kinda puzzled as to why the Vikings let Brandon Jennings walk, because even though he's not in his prime, he's a good veteran presence and productive. But even though he doesn't have an elite arm, it's clear he just needs to keep playing football and he'll improve into the class of the Dante Culpeppers and Randal Cunninghams.of the world.
Just to name a few.
Like Kaep for instance, they didn't take into account his declining stats (which QBR aside were still pretty good) on the fact that the offensive line lost not one not two but 3 starters over the course of the season I mean our starting right tackle was JONATHAN MARTIN for most of the season, or that Vernon Davis had been schemed out of the gameplan because our WR Corp consisted Anquan Boldin (great receiver) and two clones in Stevie Johnson (who was nicked up) and Michael Crabtee who all all run 4.7 40 yards dashes but don't possess Boldin route running or toughness.
Also lol at Tannehill being worse than Alex Smith when Tanehill got better with each passing year and honestly, he's kinda been playing with a team that doesn't cater to his skillset.
Also whats with the hate on Teddy Bridgewater, he's a friggin kid and he's shown flashes of being very good, I'm kinda puzzled as to why the Vikings let Brandon Jennings walk, because even though he's not in his prime, he's a good veteran presence and productive. But even though he doesn't have an elite arm, it's clear he just needs to keep playing football and he'll improve into the class of the Dante Culpeppers and Randal Cunninghams.of the world.
Just to name a few.
Last edited:
- Joined
- Oct 20, 2013
- Messages
- 18,827
- Reputation
- 2,092
- Daps
- 44,429
- Reppin
- Ruff Raleigh, North Carolina
Prove em wrong Killa 
The Luck hate doesn't even matter, he's Teflon.
Most passing yards through first three seasons any QB. Which means he's on pace to break alltime record.
More passing TDs in first three seasons than any QB not named Marino. And it's 2015 rules so Luck will just keep piling up #s. He has the cheat codes.
Already has a classic playoff performance under his belt, in addition to 12 game winning drives. Almost a season's worth of game winning drives and he's only played three years.
Most of the QBs you can compare him to are on their way out of the game..
And yeah we know Aaron Rodgers is better, but Luck's going into year #4, Rodgers was just coming off the bench in year #4
. Luck's ahead of Rodger's curve, talk to me when Luck is over 30, I'm sure he'll be elite then too.
One of these names is not like the other
Peyton 2.0The Luck hate doesn't even matter, he's Teflon.
Most passing yards through first three seasons any QB. Which means he's on pace to break alltime record.
More passing TDs in first three seasons than any QB not named Marino. And it's 2015 rules so Luck will just keep piling up #s. He has the cheat codes.
Already has a classic playoff performance under his belt, in addition to 12 game winning drives. Almost a season's worth of game winning drives and he's only played three years.
Most of the QBs you can compare him to are on their way out of the game..
And yeah we know Aaron Rodgers is better, but Luck's going into year #4, Rodgers was just coming off the bench in year #4
feelosofer
#ninergang
People look at Derek Carr from a stat standpoint not realizing the kid had fukk all to throw the ball too. As a 49ers fan, I remember how badly he ethered us last year and the funny thing was, he was either under fire or well covered for most of the throws he made. The Raiders were smart in getting Crabtree and Amari Cooper. They won't make noise next year but once Peyton retires that division is wide open.
future 2nd goat regular season qb
Peyton is one of best QBs all time and you hurling out the comparison like it's negative. Even Luck's biggest critics compare him to the greats. Amazing.
it was a compliment.