He def didn't deserve 2011 and 2012 that was reputation for sure but others were deserved. Maybe there was some defensive specialist when he was droppin 32-35 PPG ya can say deserve it more but there always arguments for other defenders.
Whats not arguable Frobe was a ELITE best perimeter defender in the game level defender. And his defense specially in help and pick and roll the biggest reason Shaq ass stopped gettin swept left and right. Since Kobe became a full time starter all of a sudden we saw peak Shaq and his poor defensive coverage outside paint not taken advantage of routinely by teams in the playoffs
Karl Malone who was routinely eliminatin Shaq when he went out west before Kobe was a starter and playin big minutes
"The pick-and-roll is designed to put the pressure on people who didn't want to play it. Yeah, I am naming names right here. Shaquille O'Neal and Charles Barkley were the absolute worst big men who ever played the pick-and-roll! And we loved it, coming down the stretch, then you threw them in the pick-and-roll because they didn't want to play it,"