James Gordon
Superstar

That and she wasnt a good singerStopped making music that would get played by the masses. Concrete Rose which dropped in 2004 doesn’t have one hit record on it. Then she took a four year break after dropping a dud. Doesn’t have anything to do with Beyonce or Rihanna.
Beyonce started putting that 1960s Motown style squeeze on anyone who looked like competition.
R&B has never recovered