Gargano is one of the Top 5 Wrestlers on the E Roster

[MenacingMonk]

No doubt about it.

DB, AJ, Gargano, who else?

 

[TL15]

DB, AJ, Seth, Cesaro, Asuka, Shinsuke, Joe, KO, Neville (if he still counts), Gable and Jordan, Cien Almas, Cedric, Gulak,

Not saying he is better or worse than any of those, but I think someone can make a list/argument where he would land at 6 or below

 

[Cool Hand Luka]

 

[mrken12]

In before Homentum gives a one star.

I agree that Gargano is one of the elite workers in the company.

Rollins would be up there too if his selling wasn't terrible and he stopped doing that Superplex into Falcon Arrow spot.

 

[Superkick Party]

He's good but there are plenty better and that's not even including the main roster

 

[MrFirst2doit]

He one of if not the only Indy darling that tells stories, sells (best in the business) , emotes, facial expressions, and uses psychology .... He also doesn't do a lot of that flippy shyt either... He's def top 5 easily

 

[Kinguno]

I love you but no

Rollins
AJ
Shin Shin
D-Bry ( man got swole and is way better than before)
Big E ( World Champ in 2019)


Gargano's selling is bad

 

[MenacingMonk]

DB, AJ, Seth, Cesaro, Asuka, Shinsuke, Joe, KO, Neville (if he still counts), Gable and Jordan, Cien Almas, Cedric, Gulak,

Aside from DB and AJ, Only one I'll give you is Almas.

DB, AJ, Almas

Asuka, Shin, Joe,KO, Cesaro (would be on top if he was singles), Seth

The rest fall beneath.

 

[MenacingMonk]

And for the record, how many of the current talent have had 3 MOTYC this year?

 

[OmegaK2099]

Right now id say yeah but theyre gonna ruin him once he gets called up

 

[MrFirst2doit]

Gargano's selling is bad

What? that's like saying steph currys shot is bad

He's the best in the company...I legit thought he was actually hurt badly in that authors of pain match ...that ladder shot to the chin...you really don't know what you are watching

 

[jackswstd]

Can't say I disagree. Almas vs Gargano at Takeover Philly is my personal MOTY for now. If they ever do Bryan vs Gargano correctly dude is beloved in that underdog role just like Bryan.

 

[Beautiful Bobby Eatin]

I love you but no

Rollins
AJ
Shin Shin
D-Bry ( man got swole and is way better than before)
Big E ( World Champ in 2019)


Gargano's selling is bad

Wait did you just imply that JOHNNY GARGANO doesnt know how to sell?

Dude can make anyone look god tier. He helped turn things around for Almas last year

 

[TOAD99]

For sure

AJ, DBry, Gargano, Seth and Almas are my top 5

It’s all personal preference tho so I can’t blame anyone having him lower

Honorable mention to Cesaro and Zayn when they’re actually allowed to wrestle

 

[ECA]

Gargano made Almas look legit and has three MOTYC. He's top 2 and he's not 2

Almas
DBry
Rollins
AJ round out the rest