Great. Now you gonna tell me about all these QBs with a better 4 year stretch or what?
Grade Peyton Mannings Bronco career
- Thread starter bl2k8
- Start date
Great. Now you gonna tell me about all these QBs with a better 4 year stretch or what?
From 2012-2014 Manning was top 3 with brady and rodgers
THIS SEASON he's like top 25ish or so based on his play on field
THIS SEASON i'll take these QBs over him
Eli
Tom
Ben
Aaron
Cam
Jameis
Bridgewater
Rivers
Fitzpatrick
Tyrod
Luck
Dalton
Mariotta
Smith
Carr
Cousins
Stafford
Ryan
Brees
Palmer
Russ
What's this thread about breh?
This was his only season with the Broncos? Thread was made before this season even started 
. You said he got an overall D. So go ahead and make that list for the last 4 years aka the subject at hand and show me how he warrants a D. I'll wait...no I won't because I know it's not coming 
.
Womb Raider
5* Gooneral
That's not logic, that's just hating at its finest.
The question isn't if he's a top 20 QB (which he obviously is), the question was to grade his career.
Giving him a D for breaking records, winning the AFC West every season and making 2 Super Bowls (winning one) is absurd
daboywonder2002
Superstar
A
anything lower is asinine
because of one ship that the defense won? the question was grade peyton manning's bronco career, not grade the Denver Broncos as a whole.
Womb Raider
5* Gooneral
Because the only reason he was signed was to win a SB and he did that. Regardless of how it happened, you cant take that away from him..
Come the fukk on ...............
AlbertPullhoez
The Takeover
Aside from this year Peyton put up good/great stats in his Broncos years, he played at a MVP level, they hadn't been at this level of success or contention since Elway left and TD tore up his knee.
Went to 2 Super Bowls and won 1, they were a Flacco hail mary from maybe going to a 3rd.
Peyton had a good run in Denver people say otherwise you just hating. I'd give him an A
Super Cheech
I Feel So Westcoast
B
I have to judge him based on what was expected vs the result
1st 3 years denver flopped in the playoffs. We all know he's god in the regular season but those 3 flops stick out in my mind.
this past season he dilfered his way to a SB and i gave him an A for it. Denver exceeded expectations
Why? What's wrong with just calling shyt what it is?
And even you are doing that, who expected him to play as well as he did or the Broncos to go to two SBs and win one? Lemme guess you expected him to throw 60 TDs and go to 3 SBs and win 2 when folks were still unsure if he could still play at a high level?
.
Womb Raider
5* Gooneral
And?
32 teams expect to win a SB every year, so by that logic 31 teams all earn an F and only one team earns an A
that's dumb as shyt
Spaceman Piff
Superstar
Womb Raider
5* Gooneral
They brought him in to win a championship. He failed.
F