Givony: It's possible that Allen's draft stock will never be higher than it was after his first-team All-ACC and All-American sophomore season, as we haven't seen him have the breakthrough we've anticipated for two years now, but I'm not necessarily sure that means it was a mistake not to leave. Listening to what Allen had to say about his reasoning for coming back in 2016, it's hard to fault him for returning to school since he clearly wasn't ready mentally for the rigors of the NBA. It's also hard to knock an academic All-American for wanting to get his college degree, which he stated was a lifelong dream.
Looking back at guys whom Allen played with or against in high school, we're already seeing a number of then-highly touted recruits who are either out of the NBA (like Cliff Alexander,
James Young, Diamond Stone, Stephen Zimmerman), close to being out of the NBA (
Rashad Vaughn,
Kevon Looney,
Dakari Johnson) or on their last legs (
Jahlil Okafor), even though they are all around the same age as Allen at 22.
With the NBA being as fickle as ever with young players, I do think that most non-lottery picks are better off coming into the league more physically and mentally ready to contribute. The roster churn we're seeing these days is significant, and teams are much less likely to waste spots on developing projects into eventual role players. Some of these guys will never get another shot, and spending your early 20s in the G League is a lot less glamorous than chasing NCAA titles at Duke.
So, I think more power to him. Unless he hates school, has injury concerns or is in desperate need of money, I would enjoy those charter flights, rockstar status on campus and every game being broadcasted on ESPN. This might be the best time of his life.