Great players in their prime, but not considered all-time greats?

[jadillac]

Any sport.

Who you got?

I thinking Chad Johnson first up.

 

[Chris Cool]

Mike vick

 

[KnickstapeCity]

David Robinson

 

[jadillac]

Mike vick

I realize much of this thread will be subjective....but for me it's hard to say Mike Vick isn't an-all time great just b/c nothing like him has ever existed before or since.

 

[HacksawJimThuggin]

Chris Webber
Shaun Alexander
Priest Holmes
Torry ****

 

[Jamal514]

Carlos Delgado

 

[Regular_P]

I realize much of this thread will be subjective....but for me it's hard to say Mike Vick isn't an-all time great just b/c nothing like him has ever existed before or since.

:smhkobe:

 

[fifth column]

Vince Carter and his cousin

 

[Ethnic Cleansing]

I realize much of this thread will be subjective....but for me it's hard to say Mike Vick isn't an-all time great just b/c nothing like him has ever existed before or since.

His throws were putrid ('cept for his contract year with the Eagles)... Hard to be an All time great based solely on running from the Qb position. Some of his runs were tho

 

[Trill Bellamy]

Bout to be Carmelo

 

[Omar Little]

T Mac

 

[I AM WARHOL]

^^^ ditto

 

[jadillac]

Bout to be Carmelo

Melo gonna go down Mitch Richmond status.

 

[Knights89]

Mark Aguirre
Rod Strickland
Gus Williams
Brad Daugherty
Mo Cheeks
Sidney Moncrief

 

[KevCo]

hmmmmm....Bo Jackson count?