Growing Everything But The Payroll: The Official 2025 New York Yankees Season Thread

Remote

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Aug 29, 2013
Messages
83,057
Reputation
25,736
Daps
373,395
Let A-Rod be the GM. No doubt he’d build a championship team within 5 years
I think it’s complicated because I’m not sure if Alex really grasps how integral advanced analytics are to today’s game.

You need a GM who at least recognizes its importance. But you don’t want a GM who disregards everything else about the game.

Maybe a GM doesn’t have to be this stats nerd to be good at his job. I imagine a lot of what a GM does has to do with negotiating contracts, networking and schmoozing other executives around the league. Setting an organizational philosophy across the Minors.

Maybe A-Rod could be great at that. Or better yet, maybe he’s smart enough to hire people around him who are good at the things he’s not good at.

And maybe Yankees fans would just prefer literally anybody to be GM instead of Brian Cashman.

There’s probably nothing wrong with that.
 

Mantis Toboggan M.D.

Drink wolf cola
Joined
Mar 18, 2014
Messages
32,979
Reputation
9,969
Daps
109,747
Reppin
Brooklyn
Let A-Rod be the GM. No doubt he’d build a championship team within 5 years

I think it’s complicated because I’m not sure if Alex really grasps how integral advanced analytics are to today’s game.

You need a GM who at least recognizes its importance. But you don’t want a GM who disregards everything else about the game.

Maybe a GM doesn’t have to be this stats nerd to be good at his job. I imagine a lot of what a GM does has to do with negotiating contracts, networking and schmoozing other executives around the league. Setting an organizational philosophy across the Minors.

Maybe A-Rod could be great at that. Or better yet, maybe he’s smart enough to hire people around him who are good at the things he’s not good at.

And maybe Yankees fans would just prefer literally anybody to be GM instead of Brian Cashman.

There’s probably nothing wrong with that.
I think Rodriguez would be best suited as a hitting coach, but I’d settle for any of John Idzik, Joe Judge, Rich Kotite, Adam Gase, Cam Cameron, David Khan, or the guys running the post 2001 St. Louis rams front office over what we’ve got now. If you told me Alex Rodriguez was being hired as GM this winter I’d be over the goddamn moon.
 

Mantis Toboggan M.D.

Drink wolf cola
Joined
Mar 18, 2014
Messages
32,979
Reputation
9,969
Daps
109,747
Reppin
Brooklyn


Didn’t think they were going all in after what happened in Toronto anyway, basically a move to shut up the fanbase that they did something at the deadline.

This motherfukker Cashman will never go for it.

:mjlol:

He’s always trying to be that smarty art a$$hole.
30 year old career .240 hitter who has never had an OBP higher than .330 and is hitting .217 this year who won’t be around long term. I’m out everyone and I suggest you all change the channel too. A textbook example of trying to do the absolute bare minimum when a move this weak makes it clear that he may as well have done nothing anyway.


Edit: he’s due $16 million next year and the year after as well? I might be turning in my fan card. Just as he’s about to get out of the DJ and hicks deals he makes another one.
 

Remote

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Aug 29, 2013
Messages
83,057
Reputation
25,736
Daps
373,395
Solid defender. Hits the ball hard. Strikes out a lot.

The prototypical player Brian Cashman targets.

He’s probably gonna be trash in the playoffs. Might hit a HR or 2.
 

tremonthustler1

aka bx_representer
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
86,230
Reputation
9,823
Daps
213,895
Reppin
My Pops Forever RIP
this is confusing.

So, St. Louis is trying to give away Arenado all winter, but the Yankees don't want him because of his salary and the years he has left and don't wanna add that much to the playroll, to where Cashman wanted them to take Stroman. Nothing happened.

McMahon makes $36 mil the rest of the way, so we're talking $8 mil gap between the two. Both can't hit. Arenado's a better defender, but unless Colorado is eating a chunk of this salary, the posturing seemed meaningless.
 
Top