Has Andrew Luck lived up to the hype?

[Pressure]

We can talk about 2014 if you want.

We can. Doesn't change the narrative. He's wildly inconsistent between seasons and misses a lot of games due to being injured. He's been inconsistent throughout the years when he's been able to be on the field and hasn't established himself as a result.

He probably ranks behind Matt Ryan if we're being honest, but his injury struggles give him the same narrative as Wentz.

He could miss a couple months right now just by working out over the summer.

 

[Based Lord Zedd]

We can. Doesn't change the narrative. He's wildly inconsistent between seasons and misses a lot of games due to being injured. He's been inconsistent throughout the years when he's been able to be on the field and hasn't established himself as a result.

He probably ranks behind Matt Ryan if we're being honest, but his injury struggles give him the same narrative as Wentz.

He could miss a couple months right now just by working out over the summer.

Don't need to change BS narratives, just need to ignore them.
Narratives don't count for anything.

Him missing "a couple of months" is about the only thing you haters can hope for. He is a threat to drop another 40 TDs if he plays the full 16 games.

 

[PHamm]

He's lived up to his draft position for Indy, which is what actually matters.
Dude is on pace this year to be one of the fastest QBs in history to hit 200 TD passes.

sorry chief These stats are meaningless in this pass happy era. Luck is a glorified stat padford

 

[Lootpack]

They mad.


They furious.

 

[Womb Raider]

Let’s call a spade a spade. Cam was having his 2nd best season ever prior to the shoulder injury. Luck went off last year. If cats can’t disparage/take away Lucks 39 TDS and Comeback Player of The Year Award, then you can’t disparage Cams 2015 MVP. The defense wasn’t the one leading those 70, 80 yard drives downfield that year. Luck is talented yes. But you don’t have to shyt on Cam to Elevate Luck. Just Saying.

Ummmm calling a spade a spade would be acknowledging that Cam was shyt last season.

And nah, Cam's MVP season was a fluke. I can post the numbers again if you'd like.

 

[LexLuthor]

Ummmm calling a spade a spade would be acknowledging that Cam was shyt last season.

And nah, Cam's MVP season was a fluke. I can post the numbers again if you'd like.

Now you’re purposely being obtuse. I already said Cam fell off after his shoulder injury last year. Before the injury he was completing 70% of his passes, and the team was 6-2. You conveniently ignored that part of the post. You can post defensive stats from that year again, but that doesn’t change the fact that he got 35 TDS and an MVP with Greg Olsen, a next to Done Jericho Cottchery, Ted Ginn, and a Rookie Philly Brown (who’s not in the league anymore and a rookie Devin Funchess.)
That’s definitely a lower tier than any pass catchers y’all have had.

And like the post above said....if Cam didn’t deserve it in 2015...I’d love to hear your opinion on who did?

 

[Womb Raider]

Now you’re purposely being obtuse. I already said Cam fell off after his shoulder injury last year. Before the injury he was completing 70% of his passes, and the team was 6-2. You conveniently ignored that part of the post. You can post defensive stats from that year again, but that doesn’t change the fact that he got 35 TDS and an MVP with Greg Olsen, a next to Done Jericho Cottchery, Ted Ginn, and a Rookie Philly Brown (who’s not in the league anymore and a rookie Devin Funchess.)
That’s definitely a lower tier than any pass catchers y’all have had.

And like the post above said....if Cam didn’t deserve it in 2015...I’d love to hear your opinion on who did?

You can call it whatever you want, Cam has never had a season where his passing stats were on par with Andrew Lucks and that’s a fact. You didn’t explicitly say Cam fell off, you said “he was having his best season before his shoulder injury” which is more credit than most of you nikkas would ever give Luck.

I don’t need to post the defensive stats again because clearly you can read but your comprehension is lacking. You give anyone that defense and they’re winning the SB but guess who choked? sCam! And he ain’t even your boy, you’s a Lions fan stay in your grave with Barry Sanders, Megatron and the rest of your wack ass franchise BOY

 

[LexLuthor]

You can call it whatever you want, Cam has never had a season where his passing stats were on par with Andrew Lucks and that’s a fact. You didn’t explicitly say Cam fell off, you said “he was having his best season before his shoulder injury” which is more credit than most of you nikkas would ever give Luck.

I don’t need to post the defensive stats again because clearly you can read but your comprehension is lacking. You give anyone that defense and they’re winning the SB but guess who choked? sCam! And he ain’t even your boy, you’s a Lions fan stay in your grave with Barry Sanders, Megatron and the rest of your wack ass franchise BOY

Wtf are you talking about? Ive never been a lions fan. Matter of fact me and you had a similar convo that ended last year with you sending negs lmao. Wasn’t you’re name Long Johnson or something like that at one point? Come on man...you went from respectful banter to posting lies lmao.

 

[Womb Raider]

Wtf are you talking about? Ive never been a lions fan. Matter of fact me and you had a similar convo that ended last year with you sending negs lmao. Wasn’t you’re name Long Johnson or something like that at one point? Come on man...you went from respectful banter to posting lies lmao.

You right I got you confused with someone else


But y’all gotta give Luck more respect that’s the point I was tryna make.

 

[LexLuthor]

You right I got you confused with someone else


But y’all gotta give Luck more respect that’s the point I was tryna make.

I gotcha. All I’m saying is I’m giving Luck his props but y’all don’t have to slander Cam like he’s Blaine Gabbert or someone..that’s it.

 

[Based Lord Zedd]

sorry chief These stats are meaningless in this pass happy era. Luck is a glorified stat padford

They aren't meaningless when he is outpacing most of his peers. If it simply came down to era, everyone in the league would be throwing 200 TDs at Luck's pace.

Who are the other QBs in this pass happy era that are going to throw 200 TDs in as little games as Luck?

You brought up Matt Stafford but he didn't do it, Luck is on pace to do it faster. He's on pace to to do it faster than anyone except Marino and Rodgers.

Does not mean he is an all time great QB, but any argument that he hasn't lived up to his expected value is nonsense.

 

[Based Lord Zedd]

Why am I even wasting my time responding to people who post trash takes like this.
Dude has been mad at Luck since 2012.

You luck stans are an embarrassment. Dont throw other elite QBs under the bus to protect luck. Hes washed and done


Fringe top 10? he in the 15-24 range at best

 

[Lootpack]

Why am I even wasting my time responding to people who post trash takes like this.
Dude has been mad at Luck since 2012.

You luck stans are an embarrassment. Dont throw other elite QBs under the bus to protect luck. Hes washed and done


Fringe top 10? he in the 15-24 range at best

:mjskiplol::mjskiplol::mjskiplol::mjskiplol:

 

[Frank Lotion]

Y'all keep talking about Cams 2015 season was a fluke.


As an Andrew luck fan....I'm still waiting for his fluke season

 

[Copy Ninja]

Hell no.

Scouts were calling him the greatest prospect to come out of college.

Not even close to Peyton.

When we played Peyton it was always 50/50. When we play Luck, it's like when we play the Steelers, almost automatic W