Higher all time: Magic Johnson vs Tim Duncan

[BigTyme Records]

Totally different players but

Both have 5 rings

Both have 3 finals mvps

Both have 2 or more regular season MVPs

Both led dynasties

Magic better on offense and Duncan better on defense

Both have a good argument for top 5 all time.

Who is higher all time to yall?

 

[The_Third_Man]

Magic

 

[Professor Emeritus]

I felt like Magic had more ability to just take over the game on offense.

But he really could be a liability on defense, whereas Duncan was one of the best in the league on that end AND could be a force offensively too.

I can see both arguments.

They're both 4-6 all time in my book.

 

[FabTrey]

duncan in the 80's is brad daughterty with better defense

 

[Shadow King]

duncan in the 80's is brad daughterty with better defense

In a faster era possibly without a stat-sacrificial system? No.

But my answer is Magic.

 

[UpAndComing]

Magic Johnson OBVIOUSLY

 

[Uncle Juice]

duncan in the 80's is brad daughterty with better defense

This is one of the dumbest posts I've read on this board. Congratulations.

 

[GPBear]

Magic

One of only four players to win NCAA and NBA championships back-to-back

 

[lightskin jermaine]

Timmy:timmy:

 

[Remote]

duncan in the 80's is brad daughterty with better defense

Negged.
Michigan scum

 

[FabTrey]

This is one of the dumbest posts I've read on this board. Congratulations.

daugherty in today's nba is prime pau at worst.

 

[Zach Lowe]

close but when it's close you go with the guard in all-time rankings for whatever reason

 

[Flex Luger]

Magic

 

[ISO]

Magic continues to be overrated

 

[10bandz]

it seems like Magic stock been dropping in recent years. I remember when a lot of guys would put Magic 2nd all time and shyt. Now guys Kobe, Bron, Duncan casually get talked about above him.