Higher all time: Magic Johnson vs Tim Duncan

[The Fire]

Magic continues to be overrated

?

 

[Treblemaka]

Magic played with a consensus top 3 player all-time who is the all time leading scorer and mvp leader.

For that reason i have to say Tim Duncan, because he accomplished the same feats as Magic with less help.

There isnt a player that played on a championship team with Duncan that im taking over Worthy (cept maybe Kawhi) let alone Kareem.

 

[Rigby.]

it seems like Magic stock been dropping in recent years. I remember when a lot of guys would put Magic 2nd all time and shyt. Now guys Kobe, Bron, Duncan casually get talked about above him.

Well the art of outside shooting is higher prioritized as years go on. but naturally oldies are gonna get passed up for whats elite in the recent past. from what I am always told Magic was bad on defense even for his era where PGs werent nearly as dynamic, so I think that plus shooting would be self-explanatory reasons why he may get slighted

 

[Reggie]

Got Magic at number 4 on my all time list followed by Duncan Shaq Wilt Kobe Dream and Bird so I gotta go with Earvin though I debate on the regular if Duncan should be over him or if I even have Tim to high.

 

[High quality poster]

Kobe is the answer

 

[BXKingPin82]

Magic continues to be overrated

man what the fukk??

 

[blankstairz]

Magic played with a consensus top 3 player all-time who is the all time leading scorer and mvp leader.

For that reason i have to say Tim Duncan, because he accomplished the same feats as Magic with less help.

There isnt a player that played on a championship team with Duncan that im taking over Worthy (cept maybe Kawhi) let alone Kareem.

You wouldn't take David Robinson over Worthy?

 

[SmoothOperator88]

Magic. I have Magic 5 Duncan 7 in my rankings.

 

[e001]

1) Jordan
2) Kareem
3) Duncan
4) Magic
...

 

[Columbo]

Kobes better then both of them and so is Lebron but Duncan is ahead Magic

 

[Jesus]

Duncan, today's NBA Magic would be greek freak with better passing and WORSE defense.

 

[Jerz]

I got Tim Duncan #2 ever.. He's a winner and does so much that goes beyond the stat sheet. He's slept on.. If he not in your top 5 - smh..

 

[Street Knowledge]

00’s West>>>>>>>>>>>>80’s West

 

[Columbo]

Magic is just Boris Diaw with a green light

 

[FabTrey]

I got Tim Duncan #2 ever.. He's a winner and does so much that goes beyond the stat sheet. He's slept on.. If he not in your top 5 - smh..

TD has nothing on KAJ. nothing