This doesn't at all negate the main problem with what she said. She's still casting the areas she won as good and virtuous, while the areas she lost as backwards and pessimistic. This is a view generally held by the liberal class who live on the coasts and benefit from the current socio-economic order, but go into any of these coastal cities and metropolises and ask the economic and racial underclasses how "progressive" and "dynamic" these places are. I don't view the coastal regions and large cities Hillary won as havens of progress, I view them as the genesis of some of the most immoral and corrupting practices in the nation.
That article I posted did a good job of explaining how the very socio-economic institutions that form the foundational structure of these "optimistic" and "diverse" coastal regions Hillary won are directly responsible for the "backwards" and pessimistic views of the areas she lost. The most lecherous and anti-progressive institutions and industries are product of the coasts. The financial institutions that maliciously destroyed the social and financial security of everyone but their operators are creatures of the coasts. The tech companies that are currently vacuuming up the industrial wealth and power of this nation while giving pittance in return are creatures of the coasts. To split the entire country into the virtuous coastal liberals and wicked middle America conservatives is a brutally ignorant act that requires one to elide even the most cursory critique of America's institutional structure in this day and age. Which is why such a belief flows so easily out of the mouth of Hillary Clinton and other liberals. They are progenitors and beneficiaries of this brutal order.
So, I live in Colorado the “coastal region” that Hillary won. During Obama’s 2nd term our economy blossomed after the recession (think marijuana had mostly a large impact for that) but we were booming economically. Housing prices were rising, unemployment was declining, small businesses were moving here in droves along with new residents. Under Obama’s term I’m seeing news of national unemployment declining, jobs being created so I’m thinking the rest of the country is experiencing the same thing as CO. Colorado is becoming racially diverse, forward-thinking (legalizing marijuana), and an optimistic region of progressive ideas. In 2016 we vote for Hillary. But I hadn’t realized Ohio, Michigan, Pennsylvania which I felt Hillary was gonna win as well were still in the shytter and upset about immigration, coal, and steel manufacturing. Trump, or a very intelligent person in Trump’s campaign, saw that and took advantage with the MAGA narrative to these ppl (America first, Build a wall, punish China, etc.). The rust belt bought it. Us “coastal regions” didn’t.
That’s what I got from Hillary’s message
