Honest question: who has a better argument than Jay Z for GOAT?

MAKAVELI25

the heir apparent
Supporter
Joined
Jun 21, 2012
Messages
19,460
Reputation
5,745
Daps
76,382
Reppin
#ByrdGang
Over half of jay zs discography is garbage,his music is vapid and doesnt resonate.


And he was a nobody when big and pac were alive.


2pac and nas are the only acceptable answers.

Nas can't make party music, that alone disqualifies you from being the GOAT. 2Pac, Jay, and Big made could make bangers, Nas.......not so much.
 

Dominic Brehetto

Rest In Piss To Your Cousin
Supporter
Joined
Jun 14, 2012
Messages
31,722
Reputation
4,289
Daps
88,499
Reppin
Family
Nas can't make party music, that alone disqualifies you from being the GOAT. 2Pac, Jay, and Big made could make bangers, Nas.......not so much.
Jay z cant make music that emotionally resonates. That alone disqualifies you from being goat.

Jay z is the one with biggies rhymes in his mouth.

Jay z is the one remaking pac songs and making them worse.

Jay z is the one who got ethered by nas.

Jay z is the one who got renegaded by em.
 
Joined
Feb 14, 2014
Messages
272,079
Reputation
67,894
Daps
594,647
:what:

brad jordan aka scarface :martin:

Scarface.jpg
 

H. Selassie

Black Royalty
Joined
Jan 6, 2015
Messages
8,708
Reputation
3,388
Daps
50,011
Scarface and Nas both have better discographies and are rawer than him on the mic IMO. Pac and Biggie were both more compelling. Eminem is bigger than he is and a better lyricist.

Guess it's all a matter of opinion but I could make a case for a few cats.
 

OfTheCross

Veteran
Joined
Mar 17, 2013
Messages
43,573
Reputation
5,084
Daps
99,080
Reppin
Keeping my overhead low, and my understand high
kobe-hilariously-confused-reaction-gif.gif

Act like You Must Love Me, Song Cry, This Can't Be Life, New Day, Murder to Excellence, etc. don't exist brehs

Can I Live, Feelin It, Lucky Me, There's Been a Murder, Soon You'll Understand, Ballad to a Fallen Soldier, Lost One, Do U Wanna Ride, Fallin', etc
 

Mac Casper

@adonnis - pull up, there's refreshments
Joined
Jul 24, 2012
Messages
18,792
Reputation
-1,996
Daps
22,596
Reppin
Love
If technical skill is a main concern for you than you have a very undeveloped criteria

It's about discography . . and Jay's discography is 50 percent garbage
 
Top