Houston, We Have Rule Changes! The Official 2023 MLB Season Thread

Regular_P

Just end the season.
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
83,372
Reputation
11,079
Daps
224,231




If he's done, Anaheim needs to shop Ohtani. And force someone to take Rendon with him, even if they have to retain some of his salary.
 

Remote

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Aug 29, 2013
Messages
84,264
Reputation
26,153
Daps
377,417




If he's done, Anaheim needs to shop Ohtani. And force someone to take Rendon with him, even if they have to retain some of his salary.

They should have traded Ohtani before the season. Or last year at the deadline.

Ohtani was always going to test free agency.

And with how great he’s playing this year, his market value has only gone up and his trade value has only gone down because no one is going to give up top prospects for him now.

But you’re right about trading Trout. When LA loses Ohtani the Angels will go back to being a bad team.

Where does Trout go? No idea.
Assuming Ohtani goes to the Dodgers, maybe the Yankees makes sense for Trout. But if the Yankees did that, they’d probably have to find somewhere to ship Stanton, and I don’t know that the Angels would swap Trout’s contract for Stanton’s contract. NYY would definitely have to include Jasson Dominguez in any deal too, which presents its own challenges.
 

Juggalo Fred

Juggalo and horrorcore enthusiast
Supporter
Joined
Sep 15, 2014
Messages
32,709
Reputation
6,492
Daps
92,242
Reppin
Juggalo island
They should have traded Ohtani before the season. Or last year at the deadline.

Ohtani was always going to test free agency.

And with how great he’s playing this year, his market value has only gone up and his trade value has only gone down because no one is going to give up top prospects for him now.

But you’re right about trading Trout. When LA loses Ohtani the Angels will go back to being a bad team.

Where does Trout go? No idea.
Assuming Ohtani goes to the Dodgers, maybe the Yankees makes sense for Trout. But if the Yankees did that, they’d probably have to find somewhere to ship Stanton, and I don’t know that the Angels would swap Trout’s contract for Stanton’s contract. NYY would definitely have to include Jasson Dominguez in any deal too, which presents its own challenges.


Yankees already have a washed up injury prone outfielder in Stanton, why would they take on Trout at this stage of his career?
 

Remote

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Aug 29, 2013
Messages
84,264
Reputation
26,153
Daps
377,417
Yankees already have a washed up injury prone outfielder in Stanton, why would they take on Trout at this stage of his career?
Mike Trout is still one of the best 5-6 hitters in baseball.

He’s not anywhere close to washed up just because he’s no longer head and shoulders above the rest of the league.
 

Juggalo Fred

Juggalo and horrorcore enthusiast
Supporter
Joined
Sep 15, 2014
Messages
32,709
Reputation
6,492
Daps
92,242
Reppin
Juggalo island
Mike Trout is still one of the best 5-6 hitters in baseball.

He’s not anywhere close to washed up just because he’s no longer head and shoulders above the rest of the league.

Judge
Ohtani
Acuna
Freeman
Mookie
Seager
Diaz
Olson
Alvarez
Ramirez

I don't know if you can even say he's top 10 this year


He's still way way better than Stanton but the Yankees don't need more outfielders unless they can someone to take Giancarlos contract
 

Remote

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Aug 29, 2013
Messages
84,264
Reputation
26,153
Daps
377,417
Judge
Ohtani
Acuna
Freeman
Mookie
Seager
Diaz
Olson
Alvarez
Ramirez

I don't know if you can even say he's top 10 this year


He's still way way better than Stanton but the Yankees don't need more outfielders unless they can someone to take Giancarlos contract
There are players currently having a better first half than Trout.

But I don’t think they’re all better than Trout.

The guys I’d have over him are Judge, Ohtani, Acuna and probably Tatis.

After that, everyone else is debatable.
 
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
200,216
Reputation
27,050
Daps
642,558
Reppin
49ers..Braves..Celtics
Someone will absolutely give up TOP prospects for Ohtani right now, even as a rental. If you trade for him as a contender, you are getting both a top of the line rotation arm and one of the best hitters in baseball. You plug two holes in your team with one trade.

Even as a rental, the Angels would get a haul.
 
Top