How the hell is my 2016 car I bought in 2019 worth more than I paid for it?

winb83

52 Years Young
Supporter
Joined
May 28, 2012
Messages
47,146
Reputation
4,051
Daps
71,338
Reppin
Michigan
KBB says my car is worth $21-24K in trade in and a new 2022 model of my same car sells for $26K.

How would the dealer even profit from such a transaction? If they gave me $21K on the low end for my car I could drive out of there with a new model for my same exact payment paying nothing out of pocket and I still owe $5.5K on mine. If they gave me the high end of that in trade in it would actually lower my payment.

My question is what they gonna do with the used car they got from me? Nobody is gonna pay that kinda money for it when I new one is a few thousand difference.
 

OfTheCross

Veteran
Joined
Mar 17, 2013
Messages
43,494
Reputation
4,974
Daps
98,917
Reppin
Keeping my overhead low, and my understand high
KBB says my car is worth $21-24K in trade in and a new 2022 model of my same car sells for $26K.

How would the dealer even profit from such a transaction? If they gave me $21K on the low end for my car I could drive out of there with a new model for my same exact payment paying nothing out of pocket and I still owe $5.5K on mine. If they gave me the high end of that in trade in it would actually lower my payment.

My question is what they gonna do with the used car they got from me? Nobody is gonna pay that kinda money for it when I new one is a few thousand difference.
Iono but I'm bout to take advantage of this
 

winb83

52 Years Young
Supporter
Joined
May 28, 2012
Messages
47,146
Reputation
4,051
Daps
71,338
Reppin
Michigan
Chip shortage and not enough cars are on lots to meet demands. I get calls from the dealership basically begging me to sell back my 2018 Accord which is worth way more now than back then.
I'm thinking of doing it. Depends on the trade in offer I get. My car was $17K before taxes. If they're offering $22-$24K I'd trade up to a new one and I don't advocate buying new cars.
 

Monoblock

Smoooth
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
30,713
Reputation
10,163
Daps
119,485
Reppin
Houston
I'm thinking of doing it. Depends on the trade in offer I get. My car was $17K before taxes. If they're offering $22-$24K I'd trade up to a new one and I don't advocate buying new cars.
I'd say go for it or at least get more information. Just know this shyt aint gonna last forever so you might want to take advantage. I actually was thinking about grabbing that new GMC Sierra Denali but like everyone else these dealerships don't have any in stock and when they do they sell out immediately 10-15k over sticker.
 

winb83

52 Years Young
Supporter
Joined
May 28, 2012
Messages
47,146
Reputation
4,051
Daps
71,338
Reppin
Michigan
Went to the dealer. They offered me more than I paid for the car but about $3.5K under what Carvana offered. Since I still owe $5.5K on the car selling it I'd have to still pay $10K to get a 2022 of the same model if I sold it to Carvana. Given the condition and mileage of my car @ under 30K miles I'll just keep it. It's not really worth it to me to pay money out of pocket to replace something that works fine and does what I need it to do. I'm also not looking to take the credit hit a hard pull and a reset of my auto loan would give me.
 

Motife43

Superstar
Joined
Feb 12, 2014
Messages
10,393
Reputation
5,340
Daps
30,649
Reppin
ATL
Chip shortage and not enough cars are on lots to meet demands. I get calls from the dealership basically begging me to sell back my 2018 Accord which is worth way more now than back then.

Yup. Copped at 17 Accord Hybrid last fall and got a mailer from the dealer the other day to bring in and sell.

Only way I'd sell is if I had a 2nd whip which I dont. This is a WOAT buyers market. From my research, Carvana/Carmax/Vroom etc are offering to more money to buy cars than traditional dealerships
 

winb83

52 Years Young
Supporter
Joined
May 28, 2012
Messages
47,146
Reputation
4,051
Daps
71,338
Reppin
Michigan
Yup. Copped at 17 Accord Hybrid last fall and got a mailer from the dealer the other day to bring in and sell.

Only way I'd sell is if I had a 2nd whip which I dont. This is a WOAT buyers market. From my research, Carvana/Carmax/Vroom etc are offering to more money to buy cars than traditional dealerships
Dealer told me I had to put down $500 and wait a month for a brand new car. I just don't see myself paying so much more to replace a car I have no real issues with because it's a 2016 and it's 2021 now.
 

CarltonJunior

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Feb 21, 2014
Messages
48,080
Reputation
5,790
Daps
133,421
Reppin
Duval County
I feel like the internet has made everything weird at this point. Buying anything at all you're getting ripped off, if your selling anything you are making out like a bandit
 
Top