How would you rank these 3 players: Tmac, Wade, Pierce

Better player

  • Tmac

    Votes: 15 37.5%
  • Piru

    Votes: 5 12.5%
  • Wade

    Votes: 20 50.0%

  • Total voters
    40

ManBearPig

half man half bearpig
Joined
May 14, 2012
Messages
27,582
Reputation
-2,690
Daps
30,048
Reppin
Chi-town
Tmac played in
No they don't. These are Wade's best seasons.

2005 - 24.1/6.8/5.2/1.6/1.1
2006 - 27.2/6.7/5.7/1.9
2009 - 30.2/7.5/5.0/2.2/1.3
2010 - 26.6/6.5/4.8/1.8/1.1
2011 - 25.5/6.4/4.6/1.5/1.1

Wade missed too many games in 07 and 08 for them to count.
Wade never played a full season and led his team to the worst record like Tmac did
 

ManBearPig

half man half bearpig
Joined
May 14, 2012
Messages
27,582
Reputation
-2,690
Daps
30,048
Reppin
Chi-town
Tmac played in
No they don't. These are Wade's best seasons.

2005 - 24.1/6.8/5.2/1.6/1.1
2006 - 27.2/6.7/5.7/1.9
2009 - 30.2/7.5/5.0/2.2/1.3
2010 - 26.6/6.5/4.8/1.8/1.1
2011 - 25.5/6.4/4.6/1.5/1.1

Wade missed too many games in 07 and 08 for them to count.
Wade never played a full season and led his team to the worst record like Tmac did
 

ManBearPig

half man half bearpig
Joined
May 14, 2012
Messages
27,582
Reputation
-2,690
Daps
30,048
Reppin
Chi-town
When Wade was surrounded by trash he was losing in the first round too, jackass. (07,09,10). Wade was at his best in 09 - 10 and he was losing in the first round to the Atlanta Hawks. That should tell you something.
Tmac lost in the first round with home court advantage bruh
 

Propaganda

Superstar
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
5,621
Reputation
1,410
Daps
18,663
Reppin
416
peak: wade, t-mac, pierce
career: wade, pierce, t-mac

i can see an argument for peak t-mac but i think wade has him. as far as careers go, that order isn't debatable.
 

TOP LAD

WOAH, HEY GUYS WELCOME TO EB GAMES /COPY THAT/
Joined
Aug 20, 2014
Messages
3,601
Reputation
-1,360
Daps
4,422
Reppin
LORDE
You guys really need to stop using stats and awards to compare players

are we not discussing legacy/ all-time status?
why on god's green earth would we not include accolades and stats?
it takes all credibility away from the argument in general and would just be opinions smashing against each other
 

954UAlreadyknow

All Star
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
9,308
Reputation
662
Daps
11,060
Reppin
NULL
Dwyane Wade vs Paul Pierce Career Resume breakdown:

Career PPG: 24.3 ppg > 21.3 ppg......winner = Wade
Career RPG: 5.0 rpg < 5.9 rpg.....winner = Pierce
Career APG: 6.0 apg > 3.8 apg....winner = Wade
Career SPG: 1.8 spg > 1.4 spg....winner = Wade
Career FG%: 49.2% > 44.7%.......winner = Wade
Allstar Appearances: 10 = 10......tie
NBA Championships: 3 > 1.......winner = Wade
Finals MVPs: 1 = 1......tie
ALL-NBA Teams: 8 > 4.........winner = Wade
ALL-Defensive Teams: 3 > 0......winner = Wade



Pierce is a better career rebounder than Wade....that's it:yeshrug:
close thread these nikkas dumb
 

Alexander The Great

I ain't gonna say this sh*t again
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
28,311
Reputation
7,425
Daps
104,077
this can't really be a question.

Wade is the best all around player of the 3 by far. Tmac is the best scorer, Wade is better at everything else, esp defense.

Wade is at worst the 4th best SG of all time.
 
Joined
Sep 12, 2013
Messages
11,695
Reputation
-133
Daps
29,239
Reppin
NYC
wade is the best combination of talent and heart between the 3 of them, so he's #1.

pierce wasn't as talented as t-mac but it wasn't really a huge disparity, plus piece is that dude you want on your side leadin the way when the chips are down. t-mac never displayed that "ice water in the veins" type attitude.

so for me it's wade > pierce > t-mac.
 
Top