If Lamar Jackson retired today, he would be a HOF right?

[David_TheMan]

Where is the evidence of him being good aside from the raiders winning two titles lol. You have a different definition of “balled”

He never even made a pro bowl lmao

Rookie of the year on offense and look at his stats they are largely in line with his era. If not for injuries he matches up very closely with Dan fouts.

 

[Blessings]

No.
Too short a prime
If Plunkett isn't in, no way in hell should Lamar be in.

Plunkett got a 47.99
Keep in mind dual-threat QBs like Lamar, Vick, Cam are at a disadvantage on metrics like this. They didn't bother including rushing stats

 

[KFBF]

Seems like the answer is no:

Pro Football QB Hall of Fame Monitor | Pro-Football-Reference.com

Pro Football QB Hall of Fame Monitor

www.pro-football-reference.com

They have him behind Brady, Rodgers, Brees, Ryan, Mahomes, the Rapist, Rivers, Wilson, Eli, Stafford and Ken Anderson.

I've never seen Anderson play. But I think Jackson has already had a superior career to Rivers and Ryan. The others I guess it depends how much you value winning Superbowls.

I think he'll end up getting in but if hia career ended today I'm not sure they'd put him in.

 

[Street Knowledge]

Nah.

Don't see how you get in the hall not throwing for 20 touchdowns or 3k yards for 3 of your 7 years in the league.

Now he have 2 o 3 more years like his mvp season then yeah but I don't see how you in the hall when 42% of your career you toward the bottom of the league for starting qb's in touchdowns and yards.

shyt like "most rushing yards ever for a quarterback" needs to have context cause he has the 3rd most attempts by a qb all time.

Becayse he’s a 3 time first team all pro and 2 time league mvp

 

[Street Knowledge]

Rookie of the year on offense and look at his stats they are largely in line with his era. If not for injuries he matches up very closely with Dan fouts.

So a rookie of the year makes you a HOF?

Again you are basically putting him in on hypotheticals.

Ken Anderson who was better than him played for awful bengals teams in the same division with the most talented team ever in the steel curtain.

 

[Street Knowledge]

Seems like the answer is no:

Pro Football QB Hall of Fame Monitor | Pro-Football-Reference.com

Pro Football QB Hall of Fame Monitor

www.pro-football-reference.com

They have him behind Brady, Rodgers, Brees, Ryan, Mahomes, the Rapist, Rivers, Wilson, Eli, Stafford and Ken Anderson.

I've never seen Anderson play. But I think Jackson has already had a superior career to Rivers and Ryan. The others I guess it depends how much you value winning Superbowls.

I think he'll end up getting in but if hia career ended today I'm not sure they'd put him in.

The moniter has Matt Ryan ahead of Patrick Mahomes and ahead of people who are in whose career he doesn’t sniff. Philip rivers is ahead of Bart Starr who was a league MVP and 5 time champion lmao.

 

[David_TheMan]

So a rookie of the year makes you a HOF?

Again you are basically putting him in on hypotheticals.

Ken Anderson who was better than him played for awful bengals teams in the same division with the most talented team ever in the steel curtain.

The two super bowls, super bowl MVP, and stats being a erage of his era would. Especially if Eli is in

 

[Blessings]

The moniter has Matt Ryan ahead of Patrick Mahomes and ahead of people who are in whose career he doesn’t sniff. Philip rivers is ahead of Bart Starr who was a league MVP and 5 time champion lmao.

Different eras
Volume (obviously Ryan has had a longer career than Mahomes)

Pro-Football-Reference HOF Monitor — Quarterback Points Breakdown​

Awards & Honors​

• AP NFL MVP: 8 points (won by only one player per year)
• Super Bowl MVP: 5 points
• First-Team All-Pro: 5 points (per selection)
• Second-Team All-Pro: 2 points (per selection)
• Pro Bowl: 1 point (per selection)

Playoff Success​

• Super Bowl Win: 5 points (per win)
• Super Bowl Appearance (non-win): 3 points (per appearance)
• Conference Championship Win (without Super Bowl win): 3 points
• Conference Championship Appearance: 1 point (per appearance)

Statistical Milestones (Career Totals)​

• 40,000 Passing Yards: 5 points
• 50,000 Passing Yards: 5 points (additional)
• 60,000 Passing Yards: 5 points (additional)
• 300 Touchdown Passes: 5 points
• 400 Touchdown Passes: 5 points (additional)
• 500 Touchdown Passes: 5 points (additional)

Seasonal League Leaders​

• League Leader in Pass Yards: 2 points (per season)
• League Leader in Pass TDs: 2 points (per season)
• League Leader in Pass Rating: 2 points (per season)

Other Recognitions​

• Offensive Player of the Year: 4 points
• Offensive Rookie of the Year: 2 points
• Comeback Player of the Year: 2 points

Bonus Adjustments​

• There are also some minor point adjustments for leading the league in other stats, winning division titles, and career longevity. The bulk of the score comes from the above.

 

[murksiderock]

Ain't even read the thread yet bit Lamar Jackson as it stands right now is one of the 15 greatest quarterbacks to play the game. And I do mean EVER. Everything from this point forward is up.

 

[Trav]

Ain't even read the thread yet bit Lamar Jackson as it stands right now is one of the 15 greatest quarterbacks to play the game. And I do mean EVER. Everything from this point forward is up.

Need to see ya 15 now...

You can even make a thread if ya want

 

[GilSho]

Lamar's going to end his career with something crazy like 60k+ passing yards and 11k + rushing yards. Would eventually be able to make a case he's a HOF based on both his passing/rushing numbers.