If Peyton becomes the 1st Starting Qb to win Rings with 2 Diff Teams is he the Goat?

PHamm

Superstar
Joined
May 12, 2012
Messages
9,341
Reputation
900
Daps
19,363
So the Texans game last year, and the Broncos the year before did not happen. Or you just talking out your ass and trying to prove that your opinion should not be taken seriously..

lol chill stanley

RkYearG#DateAgeTmOppResultGSCmpAttCmp%YdsTDIntRateY/AAY/AAttYdsY/ATDTDPtsPntYdsY/PBlck
152007172008-01-1230-162NWEJAXW 31-20*262892.86%26230141.49.3611.50210.50000000
162007182008-01-2030-170NWESDGW 21-12*223366.67%2092366.46.333.452-2-1.00000000
172007192008-02-0330-184NWENNYGL 14-17*294860.42%2661082.55.545.9600000000
PassingRushingScoringPunting
RkYearG#DateAgeTmOppResultGSCmpAttCmp%YdsTDIntRateY/AAY/AAttYdsY/ATDTDPtsPntYdsY/PBlck
182009172010-01-1032-160NWEBALL 14-33*234254.76%1542349.13.671.4000000000
PassingRushingScoringPunting
RkYearG#DateAgeTmOppResultGSCmpAttCmp%YdsTDIntRateY/AAY/AAttYdsY/ATDTDPtsPntYdsY/PBlck
192010172011-01-1633-166NWENYJL 21-28*294564.44%2992189.06.646.53221.00000000
PassingRushingScoringPunting
RkYearG#DateAgeTmOppResultGSCmpAttCmp%YdsTDIntRateY/AAY/AAttYdsY/ATDTDPtsPntYdsY/PBlck
202011172012-01-1434-164NWEDENW 45-10*263476.47%36361137.610.6812.88382.6700014848.000
212011182012-01-2234-172NWEBALW 23-20*223661.11%2390257.56.644.14620.33116000
222011192012-02-0534-186NWENYGL 17-21*274165.85%2762191.16.736.6100000000
PassingRushingScoringPunting
RkYearG#DateAgeTmOppResultGSCmpAttCmp%YdsTDIntRateY/AAY/AAttYdsY/ATDTDPtsPntYdsY/PBlck
232012172013-01-1335-163NWEHOUW 41-28*254062.50%34430115.08.6010.101-1-1.00000000
242012182013-01-2035-170NWEBALL 13-28*295453.70%3201262.35.934.63252.50000000
24 Games 55388762.34%5949422287.46.716.5456841.50331814848.000
http://www.pro-football-reference.com/players/B/BradTo00/gamelog/post/

minus the texan and bronco game, he's actually been crap since 2007 championship weekend.
 

the cool

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
23,894
Reputation
-7,544
Daps
50,482
peyton manning can win zero superbowls and he is the GOAT to me
 

Danie84

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
72,695
Reputation
13,480
Daps
132,587
Peyton's already the GOAT without all those other extremities:yeshrug:
 

AITheAnswerAI

Ethereous one
Supporter
Joined
May 11, 2012
Messages
16,969
Reputation
2,630
Daps
51,345
I feel like people are saying Peyton is the goat because it's in the moment and he's doing really well, and people are being reactionary.

I honestly think Joe Montana is the goat, and hell Marino is better than Peyton too. You guys need to take into account that it's simply easier to be a qb nowadays.
 

kingofnyc

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
27,506
Reputation
1,406
Daps
55,558
Reppin
Boogie Down BX
rYTMkoN.png

HELL NO !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
montana superbowl numbers makes him the GOAT
 
Joined
Sep 12, 2013
Messages
11,695
Reputation
-57
Daps
29,228
Reppin
NYC
The only people sayin that Manning is the #1 qb of all time are the people who wanna believe that the #1 qb of all time played during their era. Everyone wants dibs on the GOAT and everyone is gonna try and prop up the dude THEY saw play.

Whether he wins today or not Manning is already in the discussion. I repeat... in the DISCUSSION. It means feel free to bring his name up but don't be surprised if a lot of people disagree.

If it were that cut and dry and it was that obvious that he was the GOAT, there wouldn't even be a discussion.
Like Gretzky. No one asks if he was the greatest, everyone just knows.
 

nomoreneveragain

Superstar
Joined
May 9, 2012
Messages
17,448
Reputation
1,450
Daps
29,406
To me Peyton Manning is the greatest QB ever, Win or Lose. The guy is the Offensive Coordinator of his own team, the guy has a noodle arm at this stage of career and is playing the position better than Aaron Rodgers is.
I wasn't born in 1984, So I didn't see Marino/Montana

Favre's Dominance from 95-98 was a blur to me

Brady's Dominance only coincided when he duos of Randy Moss/Welker or Hernandez/Gronk

Peyton Manning can play QB with Pierre Garcon and Austin Collie and win 12 games. He already got his ring, so lets dead that Argument.

Titles are a team accomplishment ask Tom Brady and it's fukking hard to do ... in an 1 and done playoff system.
 

MikelArteta

Moderator
Staff member
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
258,025
Reputation
32,989
Daps
787,297
Reppin
Champions league
its so hard to compare qbs of different generations imo back in teh day 3,000 yards and 20 tds was considered :whoo:

i mean joe montana only threw for over 30 tds once and never threw for over 4000 yards but you got scurbs like stafford and palmer doing it like its nothing.
 
Top