I still have my iPod click wheel. The hard drive is killing itself but it still works for now, I just can't download any new files on it. I'm going to get a refurb from the Apple store. I don't like the touch because they don't have the capacity I need. But if they come out with a bigger one, I'm getting it! Usually I just leave mine in the car. I do have some stuff on my phone only because of the iPod issues. Like you, I don't like having too much on my phone music wise. I would suggest still getting one.