Is Donald Glover a top 5 talent?

Rozay Oro

2 Peter 3:9 🙏🖤☦️
Supporter
Joined
Sep 9, 2013
Messages
41,760
Reputation
5,037
Daps
75,575
His rapping isn't that good but now doesn't sound annoying with his voice getting high.

His singing is good but not that good although he went in on Riot. My favorite vocal performance by him.

His stand up isn't that good.

He's a good comedy writer though.

Good actor needless to say.
 

AlainLocke

Banned
Joined
Dec 16, 2015
Messages
16,259
Reputation
2,640
Daps
74,086
You letting past recognition cloud your vision.

No I am not, I just know the history of past entertainers.

Like, people are so eager to crown people off of ignorance and only know about shyt that happened ten years ago.

Entertainers were singers, dancers and actors in history for the most part. This specialization is recent.

You over here calling Donald Glover top 5 like Charlie Chaplain don't exist or Lena Horne don't exist.

When the man is only good at two things and only been well received for Atlanta, his role in Community and his latest album.

People do the same thing about Jamie Foxx as if he got a top 10 special, although the man is funny.

I mean Kevin Smith is a comedian, actor, director, comic book writer, and screenwriter is he top 5?

You have to actually be ranked for your efforts to count. You can't just do stuff and add it to your resume.
 

Thatrogueassdiaz

We're on the blood path now
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
30,045
Reputation
4,529
Daps
53,462
Reppin
Center self, inner self
Miles Davis is the best musician of all time though :patrice:
He wouldn't say that. In fact he usually says he considers his greatness based upon his ability to play with his contemporaries. Just the fact that he was able to play with Dizzy and Charlie and John and all the others made him feel great. Outside of that he has said that there is no great and that you can't rank art. During an interview on live TV an audience member asked him to rank his wingmen--john, bird, etc. He simply replied he couldn't do that.

For whatever reason in this country we like to rank greatness, instead of pooling greatness. There always has to be a best--which can't happen since everything is subjective and there is more than one measuring stick--and there has to be one above all. I think pooling greatness works better for art because it allows for criticism without the need to rank it amongst other great works of art. It doesn't need to be great but not greater than. It can be great along with other greats.

That's just the way I feel. I fall for it too when it comes to music, musicians, artists, writers, even sports figures. It's impossible to objective say who or what is best.
 

The Mad Titan

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 27, 2012
Messages
51,863
Reputation
13,249
Daps
129,953
He's a Jack of all trades and good at them all, but master of none.

His strongest traits are metaphors, similes and and abstract story telling and writing.

Its really really strong, but it often gets over looked.

Outside of that, hes working his way up there....at 50 if he keeps going this rate he will be
 

Mr Rager

Leader of the Delinquents
Supporter
Joined
Feb 9, 2014
Messages
15,574
Reputation
5,529
Daps
69,914
Reppin
Mars
He's good but doesnt really resonate with Black folks too much..he's an artsy Black guy that cacs have embraced.

Wrong. Black people were late to the party with Gambino. White people been loved him :manny:
 

Kyle C. Barker

Migos VERZUZ Mahalia Jackson
Joined
Feb 5, 2015
Messages
28,957
Reputation
9,802
Daps
124,552
I ain't no Donald Glover stan by any means but I'm trying to think who has done what he has done at the level hes done it and I cant think of any names :manny:


Jamie Foxx and he did it much better.

Serious and comedic Acting and he brought home an Oscar.


His standup is actually funny.

He also made better music in a more competitive generation.

Music
 

The Mad Titan

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 27, 2012
Messages
51,863
Reputation
13,249
Daps
129,953
Also me saying hes not a master of a craft isnt a shot to him, a lot of these so call masters or pure directors, actors, writers, singers, rappers, producers, and performers are much worse than what Donald dabbles in.
 

Bryan Danielson

Jmare007 x Bryan Danielson x JLova = King Ghidorah
Joined
May 16, 2012
Messages
112,389
Reputation
12,218
Daps
214,736
Reppin
#DapCity
excellent writer

everything else he's......he could do waaay better.

he needs to drop the whole "I show no emotion so people think I'm deep" gimmick cause the nikka know's he a goofball deep down.

I don’t think that’s a gimmick.... there a word for that “stoic”

Calling that is gimmick is like called Kahwi Leonard’s act a gimmick.

I know quite a few people like that and it’s just who they are
 

Bryan Danielson

Jmare007 x Bryan Danielson x JLova = King Ghidorah
Joined
May 16, 2012
Messages
112,389
Reputation
12,218
Daps
214,736
Reppin
#DapCity
Jamie Foxx and he did it much better.

Serious and comedic Acting and he brought home an Oscar.


His standup is actually funny.

He also made better music in a more competitive generation.

Music

Well that’s 1 of the 5 in the Top 5 category that @Smokin Rider brought up....:sas2:
Are there any more to bump him off that list cuz right now there’s 4 more spots he can hold:lolbron:
 
Top