Is Eminem in your top 20 Dead or Alive? [Poll]

Is Eminem one of the top 20 rappers ever?

  • Yes > Top 5

    Votes: 9 15.8%
  • Yes > Top 20

    Votes: 17 29.8%
  • No

    Votes: 31 54.4%

  • Total voters
    57

Harry B

Veteran
Joined
May 20, 2012
Messages
35,328
Reputation
-520
Daps
72,125
When and why did the internets turn on the white boy :laugh:.

Easily top 20, he's not got longevity as Nas or Jay but few goats have that.
It's like those two, Outkast, Ghostface, Common, Face mob and Who else went 10 years plus of being super dope? Snoop perhaps, but he did drop a bunch of wack shyt. Kanye now as well, but in the classic rating of a rapper it's strictly pure rap talent.

Infinite, SSEP, SSLP, MMLP, ES and every freestyle, feature etc in between :whew:

The rest :francis: :camby:
 
Last edited:

NvrCMyNut

Banned
Joined
Jul 13, 2012
Messages
11,414
Reputation
-4,185
Daps
21,908
Reppin
NULL
He's my number 1.....most overrated artist of all time

Most of his albums are straight garbage. His music ages like milk ironically, and the whole mad at my mom white kid angry act has always been terrible

I equate eminem to being the hockey of rap, shyt is borderline terrible but white people need something to relate to so they grossly operate its value
Hockey is not even popular like that, so how can it be grossly overrated? Hockey is basically Basketball on ice, with contact. how is it a 'borderline terrible' sport? Because you're not into it? If Eminem is like Hockey in any aspect it's in the fact that both things catch hate from black people for simply not being black enough.
 

SunZoo

The Legendary Super Sapien.
Supporter
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
36,738
Reputation
14,041
Daps
141,584
Reppin
T.L.C.
These types of threads are made about 2 or 3 times a month, usually by people who don't even like Eminem and are looking for people to co-sign their opinions. You see people complaining about the amount of Eminem threads yet they are rarely made by his fans, strange.

But yea, objectively speaking, if you were to put together criteria resembling something like ability, impact, influence, sales, longevity ect...things that you can grade everybody on, he'd get a top 15-20 placement from me.

Be clear, i'm not a Kanye west fan but I based on an objective criteria he's going to rank much higher than I would put him in relation to how much I fukk with him personally. He's been a huge figure in Hip Hop culture for reasons independent of my musical tastes.
 

Luck

The one true gym gawd...
Supporter
Joined
May 24, 2014
Messages
13,496
Reputation
12,010
Daps
105,473
Reppin
Chicago
Hockey is not even popular like that, so how can it be grossly overrated? Hockey is basically Basketball on ice, with contact. how is it a 'borderline terrible' sport? Because you're not into it? If Eminem is like Hockey in any aspect it's in the fact that both things catch hate from black people for simply not being black enough.

Hockey is popular out here. I can't go a day without hearing about the Blackhawks from cacs at the gym or the job

And apples are basically oranges :heh:. Can't even see the fukking puck half the time, just a bunch of players skating after it, the same with scoring, it isn't a pick up and play / easy accessible sport, etc... But if you want to debate how terrible hockey is, this isn't the place for it.

Black has nothing to do with why eminem is garbage, you're reaching for anything. He started as a gimmick troll celebrities and homosexual rapper and that went to angry suburban yelling white kid rapper. The first got old and the second was always bad
 

NvrCMyNut

Banned
Joined
Jul 13, 2012
Messages
11,414
Reputation
-4,185
Daps
21,908
Reppin
NULL
Hockey is popular out here. I can't go a day without hearing about the Blackhawks from cacs at the gym or the job

And apples are basically oranges :heh:. Can't even see the fukking puck half the time, just a bunch of players skating after it, the same with scoring, it isn't a pick up and play / easy accessible sport, etc... But if you want to debate how terrible hockey is, this isn't the place for it.

Black has nothing to do with why eminem is garbage, you're reaching for anything. He started as a gimmick troll celebrities and homosexual rapper and that went to angry suburban yelling white kid rapper. The first got old and the second was always bad


Yet almost all the disparaging posts in here, including yours are mentioning his race :sas2:
 
Last edited:

aXiom

Maximized Potential
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
11,666
Reputation
8,526
Daps
69,818
Reppin
Parc fermé
Based on skill... or content? You can't possibly deny that he can rap, subject matter is where he really loses points.

If he wasn't white he'd be in a lot of these nikkas' top 5 though :mjpls:
 

CASHAPP

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
Aug 12, 2012
Messages
26,503
Reputation
-2,470
Daps
48,364
STYLES P: “His fukking teeth should have been knocked out—that’s my reaction. But all the Black people who are sucking his cock should be ashamed of themselves. If it was a Black *****, they would have killed his ass. I can’t say something too wrong ’cause he on my label. If he apologizes, it’ll be aiight. If not, that’s fukked up.”

PAUL WALL : “If he made it as a racist song, then hell yeah he’s wrong for it. That’s very stereotypical for him to say that all Black girls want your money. That’s like saying all gay people got AIDS. If he don’t want to date Black girls, that’s cool with me. That’s just more for me. He wrong for it, but he wrong for most of the shyt he do.”

BUN B (UGK): “When did he realize he was wrong for saying that? When he got caught? It’s no way that song should have been still out there like that. Nobody should have gotten a copy of that. If he didn’t want nobody to hear it, he should have never put it on record, he had 10 years to find that tape.”

SUGE KNIGHT (CEO, DEATH ROW RECORDS) “First off, I am definitely supporting The Source on this, because they have been representing for Hip-Hop since day one. I not only fault Eminem but the people around him, who knew about this all along—including Dr. Dre. I don’t support anyone who [says they are] down with Hip-Hop and is trying to defend this racist muthafu**a. I’ve watched beefs go on in Hip-Hop where guys are ready to go to war with each other and hold grudges for years, but this is way worse and some people are ready to dismiss it. My mother is Black, my sister and my two daughters, so when he talks about Black women, there is no forgiving him.”

IRV GOTTI: “I’m a person who loves Black women. I been around Black women all my life, so I’m a defender of them. What bothers me more than the actual tape is his comment that he was dating an African American woman at the time. His words are far worse than the tape. If he would have said, ‘I was freestyling, I needed something to rhyme with lack itch, I didn’t know what I was doing,’ that’s still not an excuse, but that would have been better. Knowing this is what you think of Black women—that they *****es, sluts, hos—I ain’t never gonna ride with that.”


MALIK SHABAZZ (NEW BLACK PANTHER PARTY): “There’s clearly two standards for Black and White celebrity figures when it comes to acts they have done or allegedly committed. … You have Michael Jackson allegedly molesting children and he’s being attacked with the full force of every media in the country. … You have Kobe Bryant in the same situation, but with Eminem—who is on tape making racist comments that reveal what he feels about Black people—everything is being suppressed…. He can’t be allowed to get away with a mere retraction when the evidence on him is already in.… His Black fans should remember this and it should reflect in his future record sales.”


KILLER MIKE : “This is a Black and Latino culture and art form. If you’re not sensitive to that, then your card is
gonna be pulled. I haven’t heard the song, but I’m not in favor of White men bashing Black women. I don’t think people are gonna tolerate that.”

CROOKED I: “I think the dude is an incredible lyricist, but if you’re a racist, you get no support. If we support a racist, we cutting our own throat. If he’s racist like that, he gotta fall to the side. I want to see him on TV publicly apologize to Black women.”


SKILLZ: “If you say the word ******’ out of anger and frustration and call a girl a Black bytch, I’m pretty sure you’ll say it again. I don’t think it’s not a word he hasn’t used since then. Bottom line is I don’t appreciate Eminem using the word ******. As soon as I read his statement, I knew something was fishy. He said he was dating a girl who was ‘African-American’! I’ve never heard him use the term ‘African-American’ in his whole life, which made the whole statement look suspect to me. It’s the classic example of someone getting caught and being outta character when they try to explain themselves. It all sounds the same. Sorta like his beats”


LAZY LAZE (M.O.P): “White America has that same programmed disdain and lack of respect for Black people, and like a battered wife, we are just supposed to excuse it. We have to stand up for ourselves and hold people accountable for their actions, whether it’s Eminem, Bush or the Boston Red Sox—they wouldn’t sign a Black free agent till 1992!”
 
Last edited:

Corndog

All Star
Joined
May 11, 2012
Messages
2,724
Reputation
1,904
Daps
7,269
Reppin
NULL
Look Eminem is a hugely skilled technical rhymer, but his music is just terrible. We're talking unlistenably bad
 
Top