You and I have had discourse before, and each time, you ask half-baked azz questions as "gotchas", without even bothering to "qualify" your questions beforehand.
Also you Move goalposts, and diverge from your "Talking Point" when PROVEN wrong.
This was your ORIGINAL Question
When proven wrong, instead of acknowledging you were wrong, you MOVE the Goal Post, SMH
Ethnic Black Americans ARE A SPECIFIC LINEAGE, no matter how much "Pseudo Intellectual Hopscotch" you choose to play.
To answer your HALF-BAKED "Faux-Gotchas"...
1. "Most people that call themselves FBA would say their ancestors did not come from Africa."
ANSWER: This is false, there are SOME that deny having an origin in Africa, BUT even on here the most VOCAL FBA posters have ALL acknowledged an African origin via the Trans-Atlantic Slave trade.
We have had an ETHNOGENESIS on American Soil, thus making us "American" anyone denying this is retard.
2. "how do you define a FBA who is recently mixed with people from other countries?"
ANSWER: If a person has Partial "Ethnic Black American" ancestry then they have "Partial FBA/ADOS" ancestry, it ain't rocket science.
3. "Are Liberians FBA?"
ANSWER: Liberians are: 1. NOT AMERICAN, and 2. The ones with American Freedman Ancestry make up LESS THAN 5% of the TOTAL POPULATION. So the less than 5% have "ADOS/FBA/FREEDMEN/AA" ancestry, THE MAJORITY of the POPULATION DOES NOT HAVE "ADOS/FBA/FREEDMEN/AA" ancestry.
The BOTTOM Line, "ADOS/FBA/FREEDMEN/AA" is a specific ethnicity, just like ALL OTHER Black Ethnic Groups.
I hear ZERO people asking for other Black Ethnic groups to "Validate" and Justify why they are an Ethnic Group.
![]()
They do not acknowledge an African origin because their leader Tariq does not either. Its not just here but widespread though the internet. The whole point of creating FBA was to erase Africans and Caribbeans from black American culture and history.even on here the most VOCAL FBA posters have ALL acknowledged an African origin via the Trans-Atlantic Slave trade.
Black Americans are a distinct ethnicity like you said, I'm only referring to FBAs which seem to have their own vague definition depending on who you talk to.




