Is it fair to say that Nas is a better writer than Jay-z but Jay-z is a better rapper than Nas?

Shadow King

Quiet N***a Loud Choppa
Supporter
Joined
Oct 31, 2012
Messages
43,429
Reputation
3,690
Daps
87,292
Reppin
Hometown of Cherokee at Law
I don't agree but it's not unreasonable to say
Jay has elite songwriting but I feel like a lot of Nas best examples of songwriting aren’t even know to the masses in terms of full composition of a song, I think this a lot down to marketing and Jay being the more business savvy artist.

For example



Feels like this should have been a single.

Nas would've gotten crucified in '04/05 for releasing this as a single.
 

BmoreGorilla

Veteran
Joined
Sep 17, 2014
Messages
39,197
Reputation
31,382
Daps
254,246
Reppin
Man, woman, and child
Jay and Nas are the two best to ever do it imo. So this argument is splitting hairs becuz both of them have literally done it all. It just comes down to preference. Both have things they do better than the other but they are both incredible MCs who are mad prolific and have inspired many that came after
 

Shadow King

Quiet N***a Loud Choppa
Supporter
Joined
Oct 31, 2012
Messages
43,429
Reputation
3,690
Daps
87,292
Reppin
Hometown of Cherokee at Law
Dope line 👍🏿 Jay’s is better

Jay is speaking about what he felt. His emotions, his internal struggle. Nas, in this case, is just telling us what happened. There’s nothing intricate about it

See the problem with this discussion is there’s not enough completely objective fans of both Nas AND jay. Too many of y’all love Nas and act like jay is trash. I can’t take that type of fan seriously at ALL. They have no credibility

So don’t just post any ol Nas line like that make him better. Sometimes Nas will have better lines than jay, but jay will have some lines better than Nas.
:mjlol:
 

Pop123

Peace
Joined
May 13, 2012
Messages
29,864
Reputation
6,815
Daps
112,849
Reppin
NULL
We should just have a Jay vs Nas versus. 20 songs.

Let's settle this shyt. For the coli...
I’m down, we can cam up and all that. It fa sho fa sho gotta be some moderately nice bread on the table tho on some Cashapp ish…or else nigs ain’t doin all that, 😭. I’m bettin on Nas and I’ll get 20 to fk Jigga up…who want what!?? Clady Clad scared probably, 😏
 

BmoreGorilla

Veteran
Joined
Sep 17, 2014
Messages
39,197
Reputation
31,382
Daps
254,246
Reppin
Man, woman, and child
I’m down, we can cam up and all that. It fa sho fa sho gotta be some moderately nice bread on the table tho on some Cashapp ish…or else nigs ain’t doin all that, 😭. I’m bettin on Nas and I’ll get 20 to fk Jigga up…who want what!?? Clady Clad scared probably, 😏
Man that’s a bad idea. Y’all know damn well the coli gone ride for Nas. Even tho in a actual Versuz with a crowd and everything Jay gonna take most rounds. And I say this as someone who prefers Nas
:heh:
 

Pop123

Peace
Joined
May 13, 2012
Messages
29,864
Reputation
6,815
Daps
112,849
Reppin
NULL
Man that’s a bad idea. Y’all know damn well the coli gone ride for Nas. Even tho in an actual Versuz with a crowd and everything Jay gonna take most rounds. And I say this as someone who prefers Nas
:heh:
Sounds like a good idea for me Champion, I’m Team Esco, 😆💰, I know where I’m at.
 

L. Deezy

Veteran
Joined
May 25, 2012
Messages
39,227
Reputation
4,796
Daps
87,484
Jay and Nas are the two best to ever do it imo. So this argument is splitting hairs becuz both of them have literally done it all. It just comes down to preference. Both have things they do better than the other but they are both incredible MCs who are mad prolific and have inspired many that came after
Yeah..I wish we could just leave it at this.

Well put
 

HNIC973

R.I.P Bandana P
Joined
May 16, 2012
Messages
24,958
Reputation
2,691
Daps
49,697
Reppin
Brick City,New Jerz
20 years is a long time.

Do it now.

Unless Nas stans are scared....
Scared of what? Nas hit songs aren't his absolute best just like Jay. The Verzus would do nothing just a preference thing. Nas plays The World is Yours Jay counters Dead Presidents. Both their best shyt are the B- side type joints anyway with some singles( Nas It aint hard to tell Nas is Like Made you look Jay PSA DP Where I'm From)
 
Top