Is it safe to call Nelly's "Country Grammar" a classic

a murda

Depression is real brehs
Joined
Jun 20, 2012
Messages
7,541
Reputation
3,847
Daps
29,574
Reppin
Reppin Chi-City Southside
Nelly did have like 5 #1 singles and the album sold like 8mill wit a different sound and style..........im jus sayin:yeshrug:

did i mention that this was a DEBUT album....:youngsabo:
 

BIGDENNIS10UK

All Star
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
3,948
Reputation
186
Daps
3,395
Reppin
NULL
Nelly did have like 5 #1 singles and the album sold like 8mill wit a different sound and style..........im jus sayin:yeshrug:

did i mention that this was a DEBUT album....:youngsabo:

Britneys sold more.

We gonna call that a classic?

Stupid thread.

(and I like a couple of songs off country grammar)
 

DaveyDave

Superstar
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
16,298
Reputation
2,345
Daps
29,411
Reppin
Australia
This album sold 8.5 mill brah. That isn't a negligible feat:manny:
wtf does that have to do with the quality of the music!? it's a cool album, i copped it when it dropped but i wouldn't call it classic by any stretch of the imagination, maybe you could call the song a classic but not the whole album.
 

Nefflum nigga

Bred from insolence
Joined
Jun 17, 2012
Messages
3,908
Reputation
570
Daps
6,071
Reppin
St.louis
Near classic...

He had his own style and made it sell 8mill and he kept it hood that 1st album

My n1gga had a hook talkin bout street sweepin n1ggaz lol playin on mtv
 

Capitol

Did this work
Joined
Jun 21, 2012
Messages
15,324
Reputation
1,968
Daps
36,404
wtf does that have to do with the quality of the music!? it's a cool album, i copped it when it dropped but i wouldn't call it classic by any stretch of the imagination, maybe you could call the song a classic but not the whole album.
Read my first post in here. I never said it was a classic based on quality. I think that there is different types of classic in hip hop such as cultural, commercial, and regional classics. When an album catches fire like this and spawns hit and sells like this I don't think you can just swat it down. People are always calling shyt classic that only 8,000 people have even heard before:manny:
 

DoomzdayzV

Banned
Joined
May 28, 2012
Messages
7,077
Reputation
-968
Daps
18,327
Reppin
NULL
wtf does that have to do with the quality of the music!? it's a cool album, i copped it when it dropped but i wouldn't call it classic by any stretch of the imagination, maybe you could call the song a classic but not the whole album.

not havin it. Country Grammar is a horrible song. That hook had me like :childplease: double dutch, patty cake ass nonsense
 

DaveyDave

Superstar
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
16,298
Reputation
2,345
Daps
29,411
Reppin
Australia
Read my first post in here. I never said it was a classic based on quality. I think that there is different types of classic in hip hop such as cultural, commercial, and regional classics. When an album catches fire like this and spawns hit and sells like this I don't think you can just swat it down. People are always calling shyt classic that only 8,000 people have even heard before:manny:
how can you have a classic that is not good musically? lots of albums have sold millions & millions of records, like dude said, Britney Spears. Vanilla Ice's debut album sold millions and millions does that mean it's a classic?
 

Olu Dara

^^^^^^^^^^^^
Supporter
Joined
May 8, 2012
Messages
8,860
Reputation
1,520
Daps
19,675
fukk yall nikkas hating on country grammar, that joint is classic period
 

mastermind

Rest In Power Kobe
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
64,112
Reputation
6,422
Daps
170,866
so is Please Hammer Dont Hurt Em a classic?

how about To The Extreme by Vanilla Ice?
 

Corndog

All Star
Joined
May 11, 2012
Messages
2,353
Reputation
1,217
Daps
6,013
Reppin
NULL
:stopitslime: Why can't an album just be "successful" or "relevant" or "influential" why it gotta be "classic but based on some random weird criteria that has nothing to do with being classic"
classic is classic dog - don't gotta be making up new types of classics when we already got perfectly good words to express those thoughts/qualities.
 
Top