Is Macklemore an industry plant?

Joined
Jun 8, 2012
Messages
19,502
Reputation
10,860
Daps
65,163
Reppin
VOID
This isn't about whether this guy is talented or not or has lyrics...

It's just fishy this guy came out of nowhere seemingly. He comes off as a gimmick to me.

All I'll ever see this him as is a white dude that co-opts the struggles of gay people without actually experiencing them

And using black music to make money. All the while putting both down simulatenously and turning them into a talking point.

The thing that gets to me about this guy is this; the LGBT community has put this guy on a pedestal for championing the rights of it (which isn't a bad thing). But there have been many other black rappers that have spoken out against homophobia before him...yet that somehow has gotten erased from history as this guy came onto the scene.

I feel that the people that listen to Macklemore WOULDN'T listen to someone like Eminem so he can't even be placed on his level or on the level of other white or black rappers or rappers period. In their eyes, ALL rap/hip-hop is violent, homophobic, misogynist, criminal, and every other negative term you can think of so they wouldn't even give it a chance.

Example: I was at a bar in Bushwick and I was talking to this older white woman (about 30 something) who was a fan of his and she said that Macklemore is the only rapper she ever listened to.

Discuss...
 

L&HH

Veteran
Joined
May 18, 2012
Messages
53,799
Reputation
5,920
Daps
163,018
Reppin
PG x MD
Nah, he not dude been rapping on the underground scene of Seattle for a loooooooooooong time. He just made that Same Love song that caught the right person's attention, and he ended up on the Ellen Degeneres show. A white rapper like him with the right tracks on Ellen and the support of the gay-movement is a recipe for success
 

mson

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Sep 10, 2012
Messages
58,706
Reputation
7,739
Daps
111,223
Reppin
NULL
This isn't about whether this guy is talented or not or has lyrics...

It's just fishy this guy came out of nowhere seemingly. He comes off as a gimmick to me.

All I'll ever see this him as is a white dude that co-opts the struggles of gay people without actually experiencing them

And using black music to make money. All the while putting both down simulatenously and turning them into a talking point.

The thing that gets to me about this guy is this; the LGBT community has put this guy on a pedestal for championing the rights of it (which isn't a bad thing). But there have been many other black rappers that have spoken out against homophobia before him...yet that somehow has gotten erased from history as this guy came onto the scene.

I feel that the people that listen to Macklemore WOULDN'T listen to someone like Eminem so he can't even be placed on his level or on the level of other white or black rappers or rappers period. In their eyes, ALL rap/hip-hop is violent, homophobic, misogynist, criminal, and every other negative term you can think of so they wouldn't even give it a chance.

Example: I was at a bar in Bushwick and I was talking to this older white woman (about 30 something) who was a fan of his and she said that Macklemore is the only rapper she ever listened to.

Discuss
...

As soon as people say shyt like that I stop listening to them.
 
Joined
Jun 8, 2012
Messages
19,502
Reputation
10,860
Daps
65,163
Reppin
VOID
Nah, he not dude been rapping on the underground scene of Seattle for a loooooooooooong time. He just made that Same Love song that caught the right person's attention, and he ended up on the Ellen Degeneres show. A white rapper like him with the right tracks on Ellen and the support of the gay-movement is a recipe for success
Okay.

I do remember reading about this guy in XXL around 2010. Now that you mention it.
 

L&HH

Veteran
Joined
May 18, 2012
Messages
53,799
Reputation
5,920
Daps
163,018
Reppin
PG x MD
Okay.

I do remember reading about this guy in XXL around 2010. Now that you mention it.

Yea read up on his history. He had a decent following in Seattle well before this, even had an EP back in '09 that charted on itunes and 2011 performed at the Seattle Mariners opening day in 2011. What is clear is he did have a machine behind that helped Thrift Shop take off, Cant Hold Us was released two years ago and even Same Love (got him the original attention) was released last summer. But Thrift Shop was the song that initially took off, then they brought back Cant Hold Us and now Same Love

@Mouse nah he got some kind of label behind him, no way he gets this big truly independent. Like I said Cant Hold Us was released two years ago and it took that long for it to become a hit, somewhere along the line somebody major stepped in and started pushing it
 

2manyFCKNrappers

mentally i measure kilos
Joined
May 23, 2013
Messages
8,977
Reputation
1,630
Daps
20,472
Reppin
Brooklyn
i can't stand this cac. he's the most annoying cac of all times. he's a modern day version of vanilla ice except more pretentious, hipstery and insincere, all done under the guise of being independent and actually caring about hip hop. i despise macklemore out of everything the industry has planted and produced over the past 20 years.
 
Top