Is Mariah Carey "all I want for Christmas is you" the best Christmas song ever?

[CROM]

Gets played everywhere to the point of abuse. It's a great song but I actually prefer Ceelo Green's version just because it’s played less

Agree with this part. Never thought it was a great song…but I’m not into pop sounding songs. It is played too much, for certain!

A little love for Ray

 

[Po pimp]

Already posted on another thread but







Honorable mentions:

 

[Saint1]

Anything less and I'm pullin' black cards.

This is the right answer.

It has a good vibe, the song is on point. It isn't singing full -force "happy Christmas!" It just plays, is smooth and has a great sound.

 

[spacewraith]

My mood instantly worsens when I hear that song.

Tired of hearing it

 

[avon barksdale]

 

[BiggWebb79]

Pre c00n Kanye when he was dropping Good Friday heat before and after MBDTF dropped this Christmas gem. Which always make my Christmas playlist with the classics already mentioned in this thread.

 

[Spiider]

 

[Roger king]

The woman is a super star that has had relevance for decades now, it times to give mariah her well due credits and a round of applause

 

[JustRegularBlack]

Anything less and I'm pullin' black cards.

By far the best Christmas song.

 

[I love Latina women]

Yup

 

[Moesha’s Overbearing Dad]

Yeah Mariah has that since she's the Queen of Christmas but I'm surprised nobody has brought up this song yet

GOAT Christmas song

I can’t listen to it tho.. makes me miss my mom.. She played the hell out of this song

 

[beenz]

Anything less and I'm pullin' black cards.
Runner up:

donnie is definitely #1

I'd put boyz II men at #2

 

[beenz]

does outkast count? original players ball was DEFINITELY a christmas song.

 

[Ohene]

love it, love her, love her life.

i have a former friend who HATES it and her. this same friend is bipolar and schizophrenic so i tend to think if you don't like this song.... it's something wrong with ya. respectfully

but happy hump day yall!

mariah the goat

 

[Nymbus]

Pre c00n Kanye when he was dropping Good Friday heat before and after MBDTF dropped this Christmas gem. Which always make my Christmas playlist with the classics already mentioned in this thread.

would be better without Kanye's verses