Is Shutter Island underrated?

[NSSVO]

Great movie that I will watch at anytime

 

[Tetsuo]

I was loving the movie until that gay ass ending

 

[N*E*R*D]

I watched it once in theaters and it was great. So great I went and read the novel which was also surprisingly a great read. I do wonder how it holds up today.

 

[SnowflakesByTheOZ]

Just finished watching for the first time. I found some aspects of the movie similar to 'Inception' in terms of the dilemma of trying to decipher if reality or fantasy. Overall I feel it was a fantastic performance by Leo especially the lake scene when he killed his wife, was a bit disappointed in the ending but not a bad watch.

 

[GiantGonzalez]

Dope movie with great tension throughout

 

[FlyRy]

If anything it's overrated. It's on the IMDB top 250

 

[CourtesyFlush]

I liked it. Thought they could have done better making it creepier honestly. Like the scene where they're exploring the building full of the real crazy fukks, it wasn't nearly as suspenseful as I thought it was gonna be

Idk the movie felt like alot of buildup and not much payoff

 

[radio rahiem]

The movie is actually better on a rewatch.