Tide Run This
Veteran
Mays Ruth or Bonds
Is there a clear GOAT in baseball?
- Thread starter Colin X
- Start date
Bonds
Ruth played in a era when it was all cacs
Ruth played in a era when it was all cacs
TrebleMan
Superstar
Bonds. Even after all the controversy his peers still say dude was something else.
Matter of fact, fans of all spectrums believe he was the best they've seen/of all-time.
Matter of fact, fans of all spectrums believe he was the best they've seen/of all-time.
Last edited:
Bonds, Ken Griffey, Mays, Hank Aaron.
It's amazing baseball is a Cac dominated sport but the GOATS of the game are black
But I will add Pete Rose has the most unbreakable record in the game. NOBODY is catching that hits record
It's amazing baseball is a Cac dominated sport but the GOATS of the game are black
But I will add Pete Rose has the most unbreakable record in the game. NOBODY is catching that hits record
tremonthustler1
aka bx_representer
With or without roids?
Mantis Toboggan M.D.
I’m here for the scraps
Ruth and Aaron are both right there with him in homers and I think runs batted in too. Ruth played 483 fewer games than Barry too. He was I like Barry, but every metric goes in Ruth's favor except total home runs. .342 average, a .690 slugging percentage (Alex Rodriguez peaked at .650 by comparison), a 94-26 record as a pitcher with a 2.30 ERA I think, a disgusting number of World Series home runs including 3 separate games with 3 homers, and he led his teams to 7 rings total. I don't think you can argue against that résumé. He's definitely the best since Ruth though. No doubt there.
Ruth played in Baseball when it was a part time sport and no minorities could play. Doesn't count
I like Barry, but every metric goes in Ruth's favor except total home runs. .342 average, a .690 slugging percentage (Alex Rodriguez peaked at .650 by comparison), a 94-26 record as a pitcher with a 2.30 ERA I think, a disgusting number of World Series home runs including 3 separate games with 3 homers, and he led his teams to 7 rings total. I don't think you can argue against that résumé. He's definitely the best since Ruth though. No doubt there.
LMAO @ RUTH.
ALL THE BEST PLAYERS WERE BLACK
AND WERENT ALLOWED TO COMPETE AGAINST RUTH.
GUYS LIKE BONDS AND MAYS WERE 5 TOOL PLAYERS.
RUTH AINT SEEING THEM ON THE BASE PADS
NOR WITH THE LEATHER.
Should be Bonds but cacs gonna cry steroids and that Ruth was a dominant pitcher.
Bonds being on the juice takes away from his greatness.
Although to be clear: Bonds without the juice was a top 15 player anyway.
The argument against Ruth being that it was pre-integration can't hold up for no other reason than it's not Ruth's fault the game wasn't integrated.
Integration was huge but we can't pretend the game didn't exist pre-1947. And Ruth dominated his peers like no one before or since.
Although to be clear: Bonds without the juice was a top 15 player anyway.
The argument against Ruth being that it was pre-integration can't hold up for no other reason than it's not Ruth's fault the game wasn't integrated.
Integration was huge but we can't pretend the game didn't exist pre-1947. And Ruth dominated his peers like no one before or since.