Having the wrong position on unpopular issues makes it harder for democrats to win.
‘It’s Very Easy’: Trans Activist Tells MSNBC Democrats Can ‘Fight Back’ and Win on Trans Issues, ‘Science is On Our Side’;
- Thread starter ☑︎#VoteDemocrat
- Start date
Hit dogs everywhere
Science is on our side??? Lmaooo
What in thee entire fukk !?
Science is the very thing that proves even the idea of a transgender person, is based in nothing more than mental illness…. Science is what has proven time and time again there are only 2 genders in this world….and it’s not a matter of opinion or perception either
Everyone has the right to live their lives but trans people won’t rest until everyone is in common belief with them which is insanely narcissistic… and the saddest part is the dems are probably willing to die on that same hill with them…
The claim that science unequivocally supports the idea of only two genders and dismisses transgender identities as purely mental illness is inconsistent with current scientific understanding. Here is a summary of relevant scientific findings:
1. The Complexity of Sex and Gender
- Sex and Gender as Spectra: Modern research shows that both biological sex and gender exist along spectrums rather than as binary categories. Variations in chromosomes, hormones, and anatomy (e.g., intersex conditions) demonstrate that biological sex is not strictly male or female58.
- Brain and Body Incongruence: Studies have identified biological evidence for gender dysphoria, including genetic variants in estrogen receptor pathways that may influence brain-body incongruence in transgender individuals7.
2. Biological Basis for Transgender Identities
- Genetic Links: Research has found specific gene variations associated with transgender identities, particularly in genes involved in sex hormone signaling1.
- Neurological Findings: Neuroscience has revealed that human brains are not strictly dimorphic (male/female). Instead, most brains are a mosaic of features traditionally associated with both sexes, challenging the notion of a strict binary2.
3. Social and Cultural Dimensions
- Gender as a Social Construct: While biological sex has a basis in genetics and anatomy, gender is influenced by cultural and social factors. This distinction helps explain why gender identity can differ from biological sex8.
- Historical and Cross-Cultural Evidence: Transgender individuals have existed across cultures and history, further supporting the idea that gender diversity is a natural part of human variation6.
4. Scientific Consensus on the Gender Binary
- The belief in a strict binary framework for sex and gender has been increasingly challenged by findings in genetics, endocrinology, and neuroscience. For example, hormonal systems are not fixed or dimorphic but show significant overlap between sexes25.
Citations:
- Study reveals potential biological basis for transgender
- https://psychiatry.ucsd.edu/_files/diversity/hyde.pdf
yewtu.be | inv.nadeko.net | invidious.nerdvpn.de | iv.ggtyler.dev | invidious.jing.rocks | invidious.perennialte.ch | invidious.reallyaweso.me | invidious.privacyredirect.com | invidious.einfachzocken.eu | inv.tux.pizza | iv.nboeck.de | iv.nowhere.moe | invidious.adminforge.de | invidious.yourdevice.ch | invidious.privacydev.net- The Disturbing History of Research into Transgender Identity
- Sex Redefined: The Idea of 2 Sexes Is Overly Simplistic
- Gene variants provide insight into brain, body incongruence in transgender
- Gender Spectrum: A Scientist Explains Why Gender Isn't Binary
Answer from Perplexity: https://www.perplexity.ai/search/sc...y_jJaNtHTh.yGKBdQQ8qZg?utm_source=copy_output
Westbama Heartthrob
Irregular Zero
The claim that science unequivocally supports the idea of only two genders and dismisses transgender identities as purely mental illness is inconsistent with current scientific understanding. Here is a summary of relevant scientific findings:
1. The Complexity of Sex and Gender
- Sex and Gender as Spectra: Modern research shows that both biological sex and gender exist along spectrums rather than as binary categories. Variations in chromosomes, hormones, and anatomy (e.g., intersex conditions) demonstrate that biological sex is not strictly male or female58.
- Brain and Body Incongruence: Studies have identified biological evidence for gender dysphoria, including genetic variants in estrogen receptor pathways that may influence brain-body incongruence in transgender individuals7.
2. Biological Basis for Transgender Identities
- Genetic Links: Research has found specific gene variations associated with transgender identities, particularly in genes involved in sex hormone signaling1.
- Neurological Findings: Neuroscience has revealed that human brains are not strictly dimorphic (male/female). Instead, most brains are a mosaic of features traditionally associated with both sexes, challenging the notion of a strict binary2.
3. Social and Cultural Dimensions
- Gender as a Social Construct: While biological sex has a basis in genetics and anatomy, gender is influenced by cultural and social factors. This distinction helps explain why gender identity can differ from biological sex8.
- Historical and Cross-Cultural Evidence: Transgender individuals have existed across cultures and history, further supporting the idea that gender diversity is a natural part of human variation6.
4. Scientific Consensus on the Gender Binary
In conclusion, science does not support the claim that there are only two genders or that being transgender is solely a mental illness. Instead, evidence points to a complex interplay of biological, psychological, and social factors that shape both sex and gender.
- The belief in a strict binary framework for sex and gender has been increasingly challenged by findings in genetics, endocrinology, and neuroscience. For example, hormonal systems are not fixed or dimorphic but show significant overlap between sexes25.
Citations:
- Study reveals potential biological basis for transgender
- https://psychiatry.ucsd.edu/_files/diversity/hyde.pdf
yewtu.be | inv.nadeko.net | invidious.nerdvpn.de | iv.ggtyler.dev | invidious.jing.rocks | invidious.perennialte.ch | invidious.reallyaweso.me | invidious.privacyredirect.com | invidious.einfachzocken.eu | inv.tux.pizza | iv.nboeck.de | iv.nowhere.moe | invidious.adminforge.de | invidious.yourdevice.ch | invidious.privacydev.net- The Disturbing History of Research into Transgender Identity
- Sex Redefined: The Idea of 2 Sexes Is Overly Simplistic
- Gene variants provide insight into brain, body incongruence in transgender
- Gender Spectrum: A Scientist Explains Why Gender Isn't Binary
Answer from Perplexity: https://www.perplexity.ai/search/sc...y_jJaNtHTh.yGKBdQQ8qZg?utm_source=copy_output
Research topics before responding brehs
The claim that science unequivocally supports the idea of only two genders and dismisses transgender identities as purely mental illness is inconsistent with current scientific understanding. Here is a summary of relevant scientific findings:
1. The Complexity of Sex and Gender
- Sex and Gender as Spectra: Modern research shows that both biological sex and gender exist along spectrums rather than as binary categories. Variations in chromosomes, hormones, and anatomy (e.g., intersex conditions) demonstrate that biological sex is not strictly male or female58.
- Brain and Body Incongruence: Studies have identified biological evidence for gender dysphoria, including genetic variants in estrogen receptor pathways that may influence brain-body incongruence in transgender individuals7.
2. Biological Basis for Transgender Identities
- Genetic Links: Research has found specific gene variations associated with transgender identities, particularly in genes involved in sex hormone signaling1.
- Neurological Findings: Neuroscience has revealed that human brains are not strictly dimorphic (male/female). Instead, most brains are a mosaic of features traditionally associated with both sexes, challenging the notion of a strict binary2.
3. Social and Cultural Dimensions
- Gender as a Social Construct: While biological sex has a basis in genetics and anatomy, gender is influenced by cultural and social factors. This distinction helps explain why gender identity can differ from biological sex8.
- Historical and Cross-Cultural Evidence: Transgender individuals have existed across cultures and history, further supporting the idea that gender diversity is a natural part of human variation6.
4. Scientific Consensus on the Gender Binary
In conclusion, science does not support the claim that there are only two genders or that being transgender is solely a mental illness. Instead, evidence points to a complex interplay of biological, psychological, and social factors that shape both sex and gender.
- The belief in a strict binary framework for sex and gender has been increasingly challenged by findings in genetics, endocrinology, and neuroscience. For example, hormonal systems are not fixed or dimorphic but show significant overlap between sexes25.
Citations:
- Study reveals potential biological basis for transgender
- https://psychiatry.ucsd.edu/_files/diversity/hyde.pdf
yewtu.be | inv.nadeko.net | invidious.nerdvpn.de | iv.ggtyler.dev | invidious.jing.rocks | invidious.perennialte.ch | invidious.reallyaweso.me | invidious.privacyredirect.com | invidious.einfachzocken.eu | inv.tux.pizza | iv.nboeck.de | iv.nowhere.moe | invidious.adminforge.de | invidious.yourdevice.ch | invidious.privacydev.net- The Disturbing History of Research into Transgender Identity
- Sex Redefined: The Idea of 2 Sexes Is Overly Simplistic
- Gene variants provide insight into brain, body incongruence in transgender
- Gender Spectrum: A Scientist Explains Why Gender Isn't Binary
Answer from Perplexity: https://www.perplexity.ai/search/sc...y_jJaNtHTh.yGKBdQQ8qZg?utm_source=copy_output
don’t try to wrap this up in intellectual gloss to ignore the fact all of this has been debunked in the last few years.
this reddit post is almost 4 years old
Last edited:
Westbama Heartthrob
Irregular Zero
So if sex is binary, what's the gender of someone with swyner syndrome?
Why are you using RARE genetic disorders to defend the majority of transgenders? They are still genetically MALE, but lack physical characteristics.So if sex is binary, what's the gender of someone with swyner syndrome?
Yall keep doing this.
Its dishonest.
Westbama Heartthrob
Irregular Zero
Does rare mean they don't exist?
So if you had a wife and I fukked her two days out of the year, then that means I didn't fukk your wife, right?
Stop making these proxy culture wars the foundation of your platform.
I don’t mind those trehs having some rights within reason, but that shouldn’t be the whole platform or the main talking points.
Stick to shyt that touches most Americans like wages, healthcare, equity in education, job growth, etc.
I don’t mind those trehs having some rights within reason, but that shouldn’t be the whole platform or the main talking points.
Stick to shyt that touches most Americans like wages, healthcare, equity in education, job growth, etc.
They’re genetically male but have a deformity and disorder.Does rare mean they don't exist?
So if you had a wife and I fukked her two days out of the year, then that means I didn't fukk your wife, right?
Nice try.
Westbama Heartthrob
Irregular Zero
So you're saying men can have vulvas, correct?
Do you know what a disorder is?
A disorder is not a dimorphism.
This is the problem with people like you who learn a little biology on the weekends vs people who do this for a living.
Westbama Heartthrob
Irregular Zero
Sex is binary. Disorders don’t change that.Do you know what an answer is?
Yes or no. It's a binary, stupid
Why dont transgender biological males in the west become conservative muslim women in burkas? This entire trans debate is a sociological voluntary endeavor that displaces people with real medical disorders. On top of that, no one you have defended that has been transgender has any of these disorders.
Similar threads
