James Harden or Carmelo Anthony

23Barrettcity

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
35,503
Reputation
1,510
Daps
52,449
Reppin
NULL
:mindblown:
Well...it's not as bad as the Brandon Roy thread atleast. Close tho :skip:



Harden vs. Kobe is debatable too, right? :skip:

Because it isn't a legit question.
They aren't in same tier as players.

It pretty much is.

How is this not debatable? :comeon:

By who? :pachaha:

Outside of Kobe and Bron who has more groupies on this board than Melo? :comeon:

:laff: @ nikkas acting like this isn't a legit question. Watch Melo and Harden play and you can see they are in the same tier as players. nikkas acting like this is a Lebron or Melo question. :what:

Part of being a man, is knowing when real recognizing real. If you took that seriously, you just as big a clown as the jokers who believed that. Josh Smith isnt even the best on his own squad and never has been.

The fact that you put up stats to show how harden is comparable to Jordan and Kobe :beli: and you got greatest laker riding with you that should make you rethink your position
 

richtree

Top Shotta, None Hotta!
Joined
Aug 9, 2012
Messages
5,107
Reputation
568
Daps
9,988
Reppin
At the top.
I'd probably take melo, I've always been a fan of his offensive game. He's got the finesse and the rugged post game.

While harden is nice I can't stand the offensive flopping he's doing like prime dwade to get foul calls.
 

23Barrettcity

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
35,503
Reputation
1,510
Daps
52,449
Reppin
NULL
Kobe: 27pts 5reb 5ast

Harden: 26pts 5reb 6ast

That's pretty debatable. :skip:

Hmm looks like harden won that debate since its only about stats .:mjpls:
Can the guy play the whole season first without this type of tomfoolery
 

obarth

R.I.P Char
Poster of the Year
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
17,431
Reputation
9,697
Daps
86,656
Reppin
Pawgs with dragons
Hmm looks like harden won that debate since its only about stats .:mjpls:
Can the guy play the whole season first without this type of tomfoolery

and harden is gonna lead his team to the playoffs unlike kobe :russ:

I think it's obvious who the better player is in this case then :mjpls:

um1lw.png
 

Gil Scott-Heroin

Veteran
Bushed
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
89,679
Reputation
10,231
Daps
241,462

who_better_than_me

Time to go!!
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
27,445
Reputation
1,282
Daps
41,490
Reppin
NULL
The fact that you put up stats to show how harden is comparable to Jordan and Kobe :beli: and you got greatest laker riding with you that should make you rethink your position



My original position
Both play pedestrian defense.

Both are great scorers.

Harden is a better playmaker

Harden> Melo but its arguable either way.

You act like i put >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Melo a great scorer and thats it. Harden puts up his scoring while facilitating for his teaa.


The Knicks miss Felton horriblly because he's the playmaker for the team. Melo doesnt get the others on the floor involved as well as he's capable.

I'm not criticizing him though. He is what he is. A great scorer. Harden Brings more to the table. Both are efficent scorers but when Hardens' shot is off, he still contributes to the team. You dont get games from harden like Melo's games against the Kings, Celtics, or 76ers where he couldnt get it going offensively and ultimately end up hurting the team more than help them.

Not another player i the league i want taking last minute shot than Melp, though. he lives for those moment and excels at them.

Just my opinion.
 
Top