James Harden or Carmelo Anthony

[d o L o b]

People in here talking like Melo is so established and accomplished. He ain't. Ten years in the game, only advanced out the 1st round...once ?

And how many scoring titles dude got ? Don't he got every shot in the book ? Can't he score on everybody ? Where them titles at then ? Really tho, show me that one dominant season when Melo flat out just outscored everybody ?

Tmac had 2 of those.
Iverson had 4 of those.
Kobe had 2 of those too.
Lebron & Wade each had one of those themselves.
And Durant got the last 4!!!!!

Where's Melo's ?!?!?!


Ahhhh shyt, don't tell me this nyggas legacy gone be "the most talented scorer that never actually led the league in scoring".

That would be some underachieving as shyt.

far as Harden, kid litterally just got handed the keys to a franchise, jury still out but he's a little more versitle than what Melo's shown in his career. Ball don't stop soon as he touches it, he can make shyt happen for others.

 

[23Barrettcity]

People in here talking like Melo is so established and accomplished. He ain't. Ten years in the game, only advanced out the 1st round...once ?

And how many scoring titles dude got ? Don't he got every shot in the book ? Can't he score on everybody ? Where them titles at then ? Really tho, show me that one dominant season when Melo flat out just outscored everybody ?

Tmac had 2 of those.
Iverson had 4 of those.
Kobe had 2 of those too.
Lebron & Wade each had one of those themselves.
And Durant got the last 4!!!!!

Where's Melo's ?!?!?!


Ahhhh shyt, don't tell me this nyggas legacy gone be "the most talented scorer that never actually led the league in scoring".

That would be some underachieving as shyt.

far as Harden, kid litterally just got handed the keys to a franchise, jury still out but he's a little more versitle than what Melo's shown in his career. Ball don't stop soon as he touches it, he can make shyt happen for others.

You realize that melo has hof numbers while harden is a career 6th man getting his first chance to lead a team . And Melos lead a team to the playoff every year in the league and to the wcf . Something not harden or tmac did . how about harden finish this one season first as of right now melo has his team competing for a conference title unlike harden

 

[GreatestLaker]

He's not an allaround elite player he's only an elite scorer

He is still a better all around player than Melo.

Melo's only claim to fame is his ability to score and Durant has him beat there too.

That's bron because he's elite in every facet .

Lebron is in a league of his own. Anyone compared to Lebron will come out looking like a scrub. No shyt. Compared to the other players in the NBA not named Lebron, Durant is elite.

Yes melo is close to the player Durant is he's just not as efficient.

No he really is not. You're just a stan. So you aren't objective.

Kobe is not a better playmaker or defender anymore show me current stats that back that up

Look what Kobe did to Brandon Jennings and Kyrie Irving.

When Kobe went into playmaking mode 2 weeks ago he averaged 13 assists a game over that stretch.

 

[GreatestLaker]

People in here talking like Melo is so established and accomplished. He ain't. Ten years in the game, only advanced out the 1st round...once ?

And how many scoring titles dude got ? Don't he got every shot in the book ? Can't he score on everybody ? Where them titles at then ? Really tho, show me that one dominant season when Melo flat out just outscored everybody ?

Tmac had 2 of those.
Iverson had 4 of those.
Kobe had 2 of those too.
Lebron & Wade each had one of those themselves.
And Durant got the last 4!!!!!

Where's Melo's ?!?!?!


Ahhhh shyt, don't tell me this nyggas legacy gone be "the most talented scorer that never actually led the league in scoring".

That would be some underachieving as shyt.

far as Harden, kid litterally just got handed the keys to a franchise, jury still out but he's a little more versitle than what Melo's shown in his career. Ball don't stop soon as he touches it, he can make shyt happen for others.

Melo stans are delusional. They believe he is on Lebron and Durant's level and that he should win the MVP.

 

[23Barrettcity]

He is still a better all around player than Melo.

Melo's only claim to fame is his ability to score and Durant has him beat there too.

Lebron is in a league of his own. Anyone compared to Lebron will come out looking like a scrub. No shyt. Compared to the other players in the NBA not named Lebron, Durant is elite.


No he really is not. You're just a stan. So you aren't objective.



Look what Kobe did to Brandon Jennings and Kyrie Irving.

When Kobe went into playmaking mode 2 weekssi ago he averaged 13 assists a game over that stretch.

Are the lakers a playoff team? Is Kobe averaging 13 assists a game for the season or for 2 weeks ? As of now whos averaging more assists ?
And only a hater would say melo isn't closer to Durant than harden harden hasn't even put up stats for a season yet he's as good as melo ? Ok sure I guess he's in that Jordan , Kobe sg class that the harden Stan posted

 

[GreatestLaker]

Are the lakers a playoff team? Is Kobe averaging 13 assists a game for the season or for 2 weeks ? As of now whos averaging more assists ?
And only a hater would say melo isn't closer to Durant than harden harden hasn't even put up stats for a season yet he's as good as melo ? Ok sure I guess he's in that Jordan , Kobe sg class that the harden Stan posted

Stop bringing up Kobe, Durant, Lebron etc. when talking about Melo.

He is NO WHERE CLOSE TO BEING IN THAT CLASS.

ESPN ranked him as the 18th best player just a few months ago and you're trying to compare him to Durant?

 

[feelosofer]

Melo is the better player, Harden can get there but he has to get more efficient. If Melo had as many touches as Harden Melo would be the league leader in scoring.

 

[GreatestLaker]

Melo is the better player, Harden can get there but he has to get more efficient. If Melo had as many touches as Harden Melo would be the league leader in scoring.

Harden's True shooting percentage is over 60%. Get more efficient?

 

[HacksawJimThuggin]

I fail to see how this thread is "stupid" or being dismissed by many. What's so outlandish about it? Harden stepped up his game this season and I don't think the TS said anything about who's had the better career, the thread is talking about the present.

Fact of the matter is, their stats THIS SEASON are closer than one may realize. I'd probably lean towards Melo, but I can't really knock anyone picking Harden. I think it depends on who they were surrounded with. If I have a quality PG who can run the offense, then I'd go with Melo. If I needed a playmaker, I'd probably go with Harden.

SMH at dude saying Melo would lead the league in scoring if he got as many touches as Harden like Melo doesn't take more shots per game than Harden does.

 

[gho3st]

Harden is younger, better defender.

ONly thing Melo got over Harden is size but thats about it....



watch out though, NY niccas stan hard for Melo.

 

[Youngdev]

Greatest laker, find me the Melo stan who says he is on the same level as Bron I'll wait, I been riding with Melo since the and I'm always up here. No one believes that bron and Melo are the same player, so that's bullshyt.

It's hilarious that you guys act like a Kobe vs harden debate cant happen but a Melo vs harden debate can fukk outta here

Like harden aint way more efficient then Kobe

Melo and Kobe are the exact same efficiency wise, with Melo having the higher per this yr and shooting better from three while shooting 7 of them a game

Harden is more efficient than either

Yall talk about all these Melo stans where? Its me and a few others. It's me, 23 stat city and MVP status that's it and I don't recall any of us saying Melo was on the same tier as Bron

As for the question, right now I'm picking Melo he closes games and always puts the knicks on his back, yall always talk about playmaking, the knicks lead the league in thee point shooting, the number one reason is because of melo, he shooting them at 40% and passing out of the double consistently which always leads to a open 3 point shot...fukk raw assist numbers watch the games.

If I'm starting a franchise im picking harden he is 23 and will improve and be the best two in the league by next year.

 

[seemorecizzy]

Greatest laker, find me the Melo stan who says he is on the same level as Bron I'll wait, I been riding with Melo since the and I'm always up here. No one believes that bron and Melo are the same player, so that's bullshyt.

It's hilarious that you guys act like a Kobe vs harden debate cant happen but a Melo vs harden debate can fukk outta here

Like harden aint way more efficient then Kobe

Melo and Kobe are the exact same efficiency wise, with Melo having the higher per this yr and shooting better from three while shooting 7 of them a game

Harden is more efficient than either

Yall talk about all these Melo stans where? Its me and a few others. It's me, 23 stat city and MVP status that's it and I don't recall any of us saying Melo was on the same tier as Bron

i still dont understand why harden's name is being mentioned with these guys
clearly a troll thread
houston would trade harden for melo in a heartbeat

 

[kash10003]

you nikkas man smh

 

[kash10003]

Harden is younger, better defender.

ONly thing Melo got over Harden is size but thats about it....



watch out though, NY niccas stan hard for Melo.

 

[havoc]

Harden is better than Melo?