Jaws still says Schaub is a top ten quarterback

[Primetime21]

I can't see how anyone would put Romo over Schaub when the guy throws picks like they're nothing. That ability to improvise/evade that you cite often leads to misguided passes that end up in his own end zone.

At the end of the day, neither guy is a winner, and if I was a GM, and either was my QB, I'd be very worried.

No one has mentioned him, but I'd take Andy Dalton over Schaub, and even though his heart is a question mark sometimes, I'd take Cutler for sure.

As a Cowboys fan there are a number of QB's I'd take over Romo. Schaub is not one of them.



@ the bolded, you shyt on Romo then praise Cutler

 

[DanielAlfredsson]

As a Cowboys fan there are a number of QB's I'd take over Romo. Schaub is not one of them.



@ the bolded

So if you could have Jay Cutler instead of Tony Romo, forgetting all the contract considerations, you wouldn't?!?

Wow.

Not saying Cutler is Marino, but still...

 

[Primetime21]

So if you could have Jay Cutler instead of Tony Romo, forgetting all the contract considerations, you wouldn't?!?

Wow.

Not saying Cutler is Marino, but still...

Both these guys have been starters for 7 years, no?

Career 84.0 passer rating, 21,316 passing yards and and 136 tds vs. a career 95.6 passer rating, 25,737 passing yards and 177 tds. I understand many of you just buy the ESPN narrative on Romo but even in an awful year this past season his numbers still shyt on Cutler's Seriously what is the basis for your nuthugging of Cutler?

 

[DanielAlfredsson]

Both these guys have been starters for 7 years, no?

Career 84.0 passer rating, 21,316 passing yards and and 136 tds vs. a career 95.6 passer rating, 25,737 passing yards and 177 tds. I understand many of you just buy the ESPN narrative on Romo but even in an awful year this past season his numbers still shyt on Cutler's Seriously what is the basis for your nuthugging of Cutler?

I feel ya breh, I'm not a Cutler fan so I'm not gonna spend a ton of energy bigging dude up. I just mostly think Romo is fukking garbage.

 

[Primetime21]

I feel ya breh, I'm not a Cutler fan so I'm not gonna spend a ton of energy bigging dude up. I just mostly think Romo is fukking garbage.

Well that explains it

 

[mastermind]

As I said coming into the game and watching him during the Jets game earlier this season, Matt Schaub is a one read quarterback. You take away that first read, and he's horrible and starts getting jittery or throws the ball away.

hang on breh, he a white pocket QB. They aint supposed to be one-read types.



Jaws loves white pocket QBs, hence why he overrates them.

 

[iceberg_is_on_fire]

No particular order.

Brees
Brady
Rodgers
P. Manning
E. Manning
Stafford
Ryan
Rothlisberger

Those eight are already better. RGIII probably is too. I think at least two of Romo, Wilson, Luck, Cutler, Flacco, Rivers, Josh Freeman and Kaepernick are as well. Schaub ain't top 10...no way.

 

[SoulController]

barely top half of the league, dudes so limited. this is as far as he could ever get them

 

[Knights89]

glad people pointing out that stafford slip lol


didnt think he was all that good last year, yet alone after this past one

 

[Born2BKing]

So if you could have Jay Cutler instead of Tony Romo, forgetting all the contract considerations, you wouldn't?!?

Wow.

Not saying Cutler is Marino, but still...

fukk no, Romo >>>>>>> Cutler

 

[50CentStan]

Matt schaub fukking sucks, and so does his coach. Smh the texans will never win playing with that 1997 Denver broncos offensive playbookl kubiak jerks off too. If I was foster and Johnson I'd be asking for a trade or something.

 

[SubLyminalz]

No particular order.

Brees
Brady
Rodgers
P. Manning
E. Manning
Stafford
Ryan
Rothlisberger

Those eight are already better. RGIII probably is too. I think at least two of Romo, Wilson, Luck, Cutler, Flacco, Rivers, Josh Freeman and Kaepernick are as well. Schaub ain't top 10...no way.

stafford ahead of rg3 after this horrendous season he just had?

 

[Stone]

Schaub is what he is, an Alex Smith type that can really only manage the game. They need to start thinking about his replacment. They also need another receiver.

 

[VBM]

So Matt Schaub is better than Matthew Stafford?

Stafford. 4967 yards, 20 TDs, 17 INTs, 126 rushing yards, 4 rushing TDs, 4 fumbles lost, 59.8 completion percentage

Schaub. 4008 yards, 22 TDs, 12 INTs, -9 rushing yards, 64% completion percentage

Y'all some angry fantasy football owners or something. Calvin Johnson got tackled on the 1 yard line no less than 5-6 times this season. He plays in a division with Chicago, Minnesota and Green Bay and still put up numbers.

Houston is a team built to play with a lead. Schaub ain't that dude to come bringing you back against a team (the Jaguar game notwithstanding). He ain't a playmaker like that. Hell he looks more awkward than Matt Bonner when he even attempts to sprint, which is almost never). Stafford has the arm (and some semblance of legs....pause) to get things done if need be.

 

[VBM]

stafford ahead of rg3 after this horrendous season he just had?

The hell part of no particular order is so hard to understand?

Only reason he got the "probably" status is he's a rookie who will enter his second season with a reconstructed knee. No telling how his game will change.