Jay said he had 4 classics, but I only count 2...

[King Biko]

Every time jay stepped in the booth that shyt was classic.

 

[MINT]

jay needs to retire

 

[Reggie]

So when Jay said 4 classics I guess he meant RD BP1 TBA and MCHG. So if he aint touting some of his other albums as classic then why should we?

 

[MINT]

RD classic
BA 4.5/5
BP 4/5
AG 3.5/5
Vol 1 3/5
Vol 2 3/5
MCHG 2.5/5
Vol 3 2.5/5
BP3 2/5
BP2 1.5/5
KC 1/5


But Jay the GOAT

agree, would give RD a 4/5 though

 

[Brown Ant]

Jay-Z has no classics. It's Dark and Hell is Hot is better than all of his albums.

 

[deeznutz]

How is "it was written" not an undisputed classic? Dumb fukks

 

[Mike Otherz]

jay has 1 universal classic. same as Nas. they got a few personal classics though.

 

[nalej]

Not sure about classics but I enjoy these 4 albums all the way through.

RD
BP
AG
BA

 

[Anti-Anime]

true

American Ganster is trash smh


but Pac > nas & jay

No.

 

[PS5 Pro]

honestly, rd and the blueprint are his only classics, the rest ain't even solid

damn, I realized that Nas's disco is impossible to fukk with

Nobody ever called Reasonable Doubt a classic til Jay joined with Illuminati and they told him to say that

It has some classic songs that don't hold up over time, but at that time? Compared to everything, the album was average In Most Opinions and I'm a Jay-Z fan

Black Album is a classic tho

 

[Ronnie Lott]

Jay has 4 classics IMO


-Reasonable Doubt
-BP
-Black Album
-American Gangster