avon barksdale
i want my corners
album for album who you got?
vs
vs
Jay-z vs kanye west
- Thread starter avon barksdale
- Start date
Jay easily rank higher, not close, Jay in my top
10, Kanye nowhere near top 20.
10, Kanye nowhere near top 20.
Those collages are missing albums. Anyway it's kanye easy. There is no kanye album that you can say he put no effort into, no blatant cash grabs or uninspired records. Jay has multiple
B!tchuoffendingme
Superstar
Id put RD over any Ye album, but Jay has a whole lot of filler that Kanye doesnt have. I dont f*ck with Vol. 2, 3 (production wise, theyve aged like sh!t) Kingdom Come, BP2 or BP3. Whereas the only Ye album I dont mess with is Yeezus. Kanye's quality control was amazing up until Yeezus.
But when did Ye start working with an army of writers? Can we compare albums with a bunch of cowriters to an album like Reasonable Doubt, where 95% of it is carried by 1 nikka's rhymes?
Like, Late Registration is probably a better musical product than Black Album, but how is it even fair to make that comparison when Ye had cowriters helping him out.
But when did Ye start working with an army of writers? Can we compare albums with a bunch of cowriters to an album like Reasonable Doubt, where 95% of it is carried by 1 nikka's rhymes?
Like, Late Registration is probably a better musical product than Black Album, but how is it even fair to make that comparison when Ye had cowriters helping him out.
JetCruiser94
Pro
Jay Z ranks higher to me on skill and rapping ability of course, and to me his classic albums edge Kanyes but Kanye has more great albums to me
Jay-Z from RD to Black Album shyts all over Koonye's career. In fact, Koonye's best album (Graduation?) is barely as good as BP2.
Nah iv got Jay over Kanye overall like everyone else in this thread so far but College Dropout, Late Registration, Graduation and Twisted Fantasy all shyt over 3 or 4 of Jays Albums.
RD, TBA, Vol 1 & 3, American Gangsta, and Blueprint still give Jay a lead tho.
Still FloW
Gawd Of Shinobi
Detroit Wave
Veteran
kanye been pure 
post graduation so the camel wins by default 
post graduation so the camel wins by default