HandyWithTheSteel
Superstar
This would be a respectable old head list if not for Karl Malone. Why not just put Hakeem there?
fukking Karl Malone?
fukking Karl Malone?
Julius Erving (Dr.J) Lists his top 10 players of All Time
- Thread starter CHICAGO
- Start date
BK The Great
Veteran
That list is full of holes.
people mad because he didnt list a bunch of 90s-00s players.
people should instead be researching why these players are on this list and OG lists, but instead they get mad that a top 50 player that they grew up on recently, isnt in the all-time top 10 of someone whos been around longer.
why would you expect kobe on there?
a forced trendy pick of the 2020s. you think a guy in his 70s cares about that??
i only have half of these names in my top 10.
lebron - will likely be added when he reitres. you have to be retired to make his list.
Bird is the only real snub.
Shaq is in my top 10 too,
i literally have hakeem & duncan at 11 & 12.
kobe is in my top 15-20.
people should instead be researching why these players are on this list and OG lists, but instead they get mad that a top 50 player that they grew up on recently, isnt in the all-time top 10 of someone whos been around longer.
why would you expect kobe on there?
a forced trendy pick of the 2020s. you think a guy in his 70s cares about that??
i only have half of these names in my top 10.
lebron - will likely be added when he reitres. you have to be retired to make his list.
Bird is the only real snub.
Shaq is in my top 10 too,
i literally have hakeem & duncan at 11 & 12.
kobe is in my top 15-20.
Last edited:
Tell me exactly what's respectable about having Tiny Archibald over a Larry Bird or Hakeem unless the dude is your breh breh?This would be a respectable old head list if not for Karl Malone. Why not just put Hakeem there?
fukking Karl Malone?
The list is trash, I'd like to say that the list is consistent but not even that. You can see that when he came to the bottom two he started tweaking
Last edited:
Flex Luger
Job Is Finished
people mad because he didnt list a bunch of 90s-00s players.
people should instead be researching why these players are on this list and OG lists, but instead they get mad that a top 50 player that they grew up on recently, isnt in the all-time top 10 of someone whos been around longer.
why would you expect kobe on there?
a forced trendy pick of the 2020s. you think a guy in his 70s cares about that??
i only have half of these names in my top 10.
lebron - will likely be added when he reitres. you have to be retired to make his list.
Bird is the only real snub.
Shaq is in my top 10 too,
i literally have hakeem & duncan at 11 & 12.
kobe is in my top 15-20.
Go home Wacky D
And you're in here acting like he wasn't a habitual choker and playoff underachiever.
nikkaS IN HERE
ACTING LIKE THE MAILMAN
ISNT A 2X MVP,
3RD ALL TIME LEADING SCORER.
I'm not gonna sit here and argue another man's opinion, especially someone who has a resume like Dr. J... I think this just illustrates how people romanticize players of their generation and generally speaking dismiss the newer guys.
40 years from now you'll hear people claim Kobe, Wade and Bron were overrated. It's just the way things go.
40 years from now you'll hear people claim Kobe, Wade and Bron were overrated. It's just the way things go.
Great list
Why would anyone have an issue with Dr J's all time list? It's HIS list!! If one ask ANY HOF Legend or any current NBA player as well as those in between the same question, then the list will vary....
I know my list would be different and I am sure the same could be said about any poster her as well as any NBA fan...
*shrugs*
I know my list would be different and I am sure the same could be said about any poster her as well as any NBA fan...
*shrugs*
DJ Paul's Arm
Veteran
Whips-n-Chains
Chi
Mailman doesn’t deliver on Sundays. And should never sniff any all time list
etrofllenrod504
All Star
shyt 3 mvps 3 scoring titles and 2 chips in the beginning of your pro career just to have someone tell you that shyt don’t matter. I’d be salty too.
FunkDoc1112
Heavily Armed
PF is probably the most ill defined position. Most PFs tend to either be closet centers, brolic/doughy SFs, or offensively challenged SFs with strong defense
GreatestLaker
#FirePelinka
all his accolades, stats, accomplishments etc dropped when he joined the NBA. And he was only 26.
"JOINED" THE NBA?
HE WAS WITH THE ABA
WHEN THE 2 LEAGUES MERGED.
HIS shyt SOULD STILL COUNT
IN A MERGER.
