I actually think the way Microsoft handles it is better. Have a problem with your batteries you can grab a couple of rechargeable ones cheap instead of possibly having to replace the controller.
But it's 2015...using 1975 antics.
I mean I "get" it, but the DS4 battery life thing is completely overblown. Vast majority love it.
Gonna try out these new thumbsticks later this week on my blue DS4 on the way.