Justin Herpert is Just A Guy

[MikelArteta]

Play nothing alike

I meant in the sense carr put up numbers 32 tds 13 picks, 28 tds 6 picks. Almost 4,000 passing yards etc. but was just a guy that was overrated by cacs and never won anything.

justin herbert has put up gaudy stats his first three seasons, but as well just a guy

 

[ryderldb]

Nah, he and Staley got something special cooking. Give them another 4/5 years together and you'll see

I see the vision

 

[Ohene]

It's very fun how the black QBs don't get these same benefits. I just want to know what makes people think he's a top 5 QB?

his decision making is trash
and he might be the worst QB there is in clutch/key moments

dude constantly turns it over in the redzone

 

[keond]

He is the prototypical tall white guy pocket Qb, that SHOULD be great, let’s just say it. The reason he doesn’t get criticized is that he’s quiet and he looks like a QB that was created in a lab. If he was a flashy running QB named Jaquan Hebert, he would be catching hell


His results don’t match the hype

 

[Max Power]

Them Black boys with better records and actual playoff wins had to basically beg to get paid

Hurts got the bag immediately
Watson was almost 2 years out and got the largest guaranteed contract in nfl history
Lamar was offered the bag, turned it down, bet on himself and got an even bigger bag.
Mahomes situation is taken care of for the rest of his career.
Washed Russell Wilson getting paid in Denver.


Who had to beg?

 

[Stone]

It's very fun how the black QBs don't get these same benefits. I just want to know what makes people think he's a top 5 QB?

You got Mahomes and Lamar. Maybe Josh Allen over him?

 

[xXMASHERXx]

You got Mahomes and Lamar. Maybe Josh Allen over him?

Why not Hurts and Burrow? What has he done to be considered better than any these names?

 

[Joe Sixpack]

Horrific thread

 

[Joe Sixpack]

I just don't see it with this dude....A less motivated Dan Marino....Chargers will be at most a divisional round contender for the duration of his contract

Log off

 

[KidJSoul]

He had people wide open last game . Mahomes has one person you can call a weapon

But Kelce is open every play in the middle of the field

 

[North of Death]

Log off

Hes just a guy..nothing more nothing less....

 

[Stone]

Why not Hurts and Burrow? What has he done to be considered better than any these names?

Burrow imo is basically Herbert but he had the benefit of the better QB in his division getting hurt the last 2 seasons.

Hurts basically had one good year. Kinda shaky this year.

Only guys in the league I would say are definitely better are the ones I just mentioned

 

[Stone]

But Kelce is open every play in the middle of the field

This probably my favorite subplot of this forum lmao

 

[Roid Jones]

Herbert on the Phins with Mcdaniels is running through the league

Shyt would be Madden in real life

 

[xXMASHERXx]

Burrow imo is basically Herbert but he had the benefit of the better QB in his division getting hurt the last 2 seasons.

Hurts basically had one good year. Kinda shaky this year.

Only guys in the league I would say are definitely better are the ones I just mentioned

Hurt's 1 good year is better than Herbert has ever looked. Why try to discredit the accomplishments of other QBs to overrate this guy. You still didn't answer the question. Why is he better than Hurts and Burrow?