Justin Herpert is Just A Guy

[MyApps]

Watson has a worse winning % and hasn't been a good QB since 2019, you're a moron.

Clearly his shoulder had him messed up this whole year, which is why he had season ending surgery DESPITE his team doctors being completely incompetent on the matter.

He's been out of the league for 2 and a half seasons since 2019 because of a legal matter NOT because of his play.

Watson has won his division something like 3 times and was prime to possibly do it again this season (was 5-1 as a starter I believe)

Yet you want to go off of winning percentage of a QB that lost a playoff game despite being up 27-0 in the 2nd quarter?

And I'm the moron?

 

[Shadow King]

Other than Mahomes there's no QB that would have a winning record with this team and coach. 19 tds 5 ints 100 passer rating.

I wouldn't go this far but yes Herbert gets too much blame.

Kirk is a Franchise QB.

NOT a top 5 QB.

There's a difference.

Kirk is a franchise QB, but he spent years proving himself and playing on franchise tags after 5 years of school. He never fit the billing of "star QB who blows up during rookie deal, must extend him to build for 10 years". Herbert does and got paid as such.

 

[28 Gramz]

Clearly his shoulder had him messed up this whole year, which is why he had season ending surgery DESPITE his team doctors being completely incompetent on the matter.

He's been out of the league for 2 and a half seasons since 2019 because of a legal matter NOT because of his play.

Watson has won his division something like 3 times and was prime to possibly do it again this season (was 5-1 as a starter I believe)

Yet you want to go off of winning percentage of a QB that lost a playoff game despite being up 27-0 in the 2nd quarter?

And I'm the moron?

Yes Watson was winning his awful division which was similar to todays NFC south while Herbert is in a division with the Chiefs. QB wins are meaningless in a debate about who is the actual better player unless you think Kenny Pickett is also >>Herbert. Dont bring up injuries unless you wanna talk about the cracked ribs and broken finger that Herbert has played through.

And am I trippin or did Watson have a 24-0 lead on KC and blew it in embarrassing fashion

 

[King Kreole]

How is he clearly Top 5?

I'd trust a healthy Watson over Herbert any day

 

[King Kreole]

This thread is deranged. Herbert is clearly a top 5 QB. Only guys who are definitively above him are Mahomes and Lamar. Burrow is actually who y'all claiming Herbert to be. Most overrated QB in the league.

 

[holidayinn21]

That Belichick glow up when he goes from Mac Jones to Herbert

 

[MyApps]

Yes Watson was winning his awful division which was similar to todays NFC south while Herbert is in a division with the Chiefs. QB wins are meaningless in a debate about who is the actual better player unless you think Kenny Pickett is also >>Herbert. Dont bring up injuries unless you wanna talk about the cracked ribs and broken finger that Herbert has played through.

And am I trippin or did Watson have a 24-0 lead on KC and blew it in embarrassing fashion

You were the one bringing up winning percentages not me.



And a fractured shoulder on your throwing arm is far worse than ribs or a finger.



And Watson lost that lead To MAHOMES not no damn Overrated Trevor Lawrence.

 

[premier58]

That Belichick glow up when he goes from Mac Jones to Herbert

Chargers arent paying Belichick 20 million a year.

 

[MyApps]

This thread is deranged. Herbert is clearly a top 5 QB. Only guys who are definitively above him are Mahomes and Lamar. Burrow is actually who y'all claiming Herbert to be. Most overrated QB in the league.

Nikka

What has Herbert ever done???

This is asinine. And I'm not a fan of Burrow either.

Yall trippin.

 

[28 Gramz]

You were the one bringing up winning percentages not me.



And a fractured shoulder on your throwing arm is far worse than ribs or a finger.



And Watson lost that lead To MAHOMES not no damn Overrated Trevor Lawrence.

Watson was throwing against the garbage KC defense of that year, even bigger L

 

[#1 pick]

He would be fine if cacs wasn't retards selling him as an elite QB and going super hard at it

 

[Rekkapryde]

This thread is deranged. Herbert is clearly a top 5 QB. Only guys who are definitively above him are Mahomes and Lamar. Burrow is actually who y'all claiming Herbert to be. Most overrated QB in the league.

don't agree.

Pat
Lamar
Jalen Hurts
Josh (more Klutch)
Joe Burrow (even though more injury prone than Lamar....but that's another story)
Dak (dead ass serious)
Goff
Healthy Nasty Man

 

[#1 pick]

don't agree.

Pat
Lamar
Jalen Hurts
Josh (more Klutch)
Joe Burrow (even though more injury prone than Lamar....but that's another story)
Dak (dead ass serious)
Goff
Healthy Nasty Man

He's a top 8-16 QB any given Sunday.

 

[L. Deezy]

Herbert needs a quality coach...

His team lets him down every week damn near.. either Staley trash defensive mind or offense that always puts him in come from behind mode.

I swear almost every week he asked to win on a final drive. Ive never seen that so much in all my life of watching football..

 

[L. Deezy]

don't agree.

Pat
Lamar
Jalen Hurts
Josh (more Klutch)
Joe Burrow (even though more injury prone than Lamar....but that's another story)
Dak (dead ass serious)
Goff
Healthy Nasty Man

Just stop.. you got to be kidding..